Insurer reviews
Car Insurance Companies in South Africa: 21 Reviewed (2026)
South Africa’s car insurance companies sell in three ways: direct, online and by phone; through brokers and advisers; and through the banks. On Hellopeter’s car insurance ranking, seen on 12 November 2026, OUTsurance, Prime South Africa and Old Mutual Insure are the first three by TrustIndex.1 On the National Financial Ombud’s 2025 figures, OUTsurance had the lowest resolved ratio of the car insurers in its top 25, at 3%.2 No single measure ranks them all the same way, so the table below sets five side by side for 21 insurers.
Updated 12 November 2026 · Reviewed by the OneCompare Editorial team, 12 November 2026
Car insurance companies compared on service
Five measures for each insurer, read from the people who publish them. Hellopeter’s rank is its place in the car insurance category, which it orders by TrustIndex; the ombud’s figure is the share of complaints it closed that ended with something for the policyholder; the CE Index is the University of Pretoria’s 2025 customer experience study, as reported by MoneyMarketing.1,2,3
| Insurer | Hellopeter car insurance rank, stars (reviews in 12 months) | Ombud 2025 resolved ratio | 2025 CE Index | Claims line | How it sells |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st for Women | #12: 4.6 stars (6,158)1 | 9% | In the top 5 overall | 0861 33 93 394 | Direct |
| Absa | #19: 4.5 stars (5,727)1 | 13% | – | 0860 100 8765 | Bank |
| Auto & General | #14: 4.6 stars (7,635)1 | 4% | 1st overall (73.7); highest NPS (33) | 0861 60 01 246 | Direct |
| Budget | #7: 4.7 stars (12,043)1 | 4% | Joint 2nd overall; joint top on digital | Road Assist 0860 10 42 11; claims after login7 | Direct |
| Dial Direct | #10: 4.7 stars (2,172)1 | Not in the top 25 | In the top 5 overall; product category winner | 0861 555 5808 | Direct |
| Discovery Insure | Not in the car category; its profile: 4.0 stars (1,810)9 | 10% | Strongest broker-channel experience, with MiWay | 0860 751 75110 | Online, by phone or through a financial adviser11 |
| Dotsure | #6: 4.8 stars (6,746)1 | 7% | – | 0861 368 787312 | Direct |
| FNB | No profile for its insurance alone | 13% | – | 087 312 000113 | Bank |
| Hollard | Not in the car category; its profile: 3.6 stars (242)14 | 12% | – | Its contact page sends car customers to Dotsure15 | Brokers and advisers16 |
| iWYZE | #11: 4.6 stars (3,466)1 | 10% (Old Mutual Insure, its underwriter) | – | 0860 93 94 9317 | Direct |
| King Price | #4: 4.8 stars (17,505)1 | 4% | – | 0860 50 50 50, option 118 | Direct |
| MiWay | #5: 4.8 stars (28,797)1 | 5% | Strongest broker-channel experience, with Discovery Insure | 0860 64 64 6419 | Direct; the CE Index counts it as broker-led3 |
| Momentum Insure | #18: 4.6 stars (2,196)1 | 11% | – | 0860 006 78420 | Direct |
| Naked | #15: 4.6 stars (2,298)1 | Not in the top 25 | – | In the app; emergencies 0860 995 12521 | Direct, by app |
| Nedbank | – | 9% (Nedgroup Insurance) | – | 0800 333 11122 | Bank |
| Old Mutual Insure | #3: 4.8 stars (3,492)1 | 10% | – | 0861 24 7 36523 | Direct |
| OUTsurance | #1: 4.8 stars (26,343)1 | 3% | Problem resolution 78% | 08 600 70 00024 | Direct |
| Pineapple | #17: 4.6 stars (6,758)1 | 17% (OMART, its underwriter) | – | +27 12 493 400525 | Direct, by app |
| Santam | #9: 4.8 stars (9,445)1 | 7% | – | 0860 505 91126 | Online, or Santam Direct27 |
| Standard Bank | Not in the car category; its profile: 1.3 stars (550)28 | 7% (Standard Insurance) | – | 0860 123 44429 | Bank |
| Virseker | #16: 4.6 stars (1,422)1 | 4% (Auto & General, its insurer) | Joint 2nd overall | 0861 47 79 1130 | Direct |
Hellopeter seen 12 November 2026. Ombud figures for 2025, by licence, so an underwriter’s row covers every brand it carries; “not in the top 25” means the ombud published no row for that licence. A dash means the measure publishes no figure for the insurer. Alphabetical order.
Top 10 car insurance companies by Hellopeter rating (seen 12 November 2026)
This is Hellopeter’s own order for its car insurance category. Hellopeter says TrustIndex “combines customer star ratings with how quickly the business replies to all its reviews, over the last 12 months”, so a quick reply counts as well as a high score.1
- OUTsurance: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 26,343 reviews in the last 12 months
- Prime South Africa: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 16,313 reviews in the last 12 months
- Old Mutual Insure: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 3,492 reviews in the last 12 months
- King Price: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 17,505 reviews in the last 12 months
- MiWay: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 28,797 reviews in the last 12 months
- Dotsure: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 6,746 reviews in the last 12 months
- Budget: TrustIndex 10, 4.7 stars from 12,043 reviews in the last 12 months
- Oneplan: TrustIndex 10, 4.7 stars from 4,110 reviews in the last 12 months
- Santam: TrustIndex 10, 4.8 stars from 9,445 reviews in the last 12 months
- Dial Direct: TrustIndex 10, 4.7 stars from 2,172 reviews in the last 12 months
Other measures put these companies in a different order. On the ombud’s 2025 resolved ratios the lowest were OUTsurance at 3% and King Price, Auto & General and Budget at 4% each, and on the 2025 CE Index Auto & General came first overall.2,3 Prime South Africa and Oneplan aren’t in our review series of 21 insurers.
How to read each measure
Hellopeter stars and TrustIndex
Stars are what reviewers gave; TrustIndex adds how fast the company answers them. A company with many recent reviews and quick replies rises in the ranking even when its stars match a smaller rival’s. Read the number of reviews beside the stars: 4.8 from 26,000 reviews and 4.8 from 3,000 are both real, but they rest on very different amounts of feedback.1 The CE Index’s author also notes that some insurers direct customers to platforms such as Hellopeter straight after a service call, which, he says, inflates advocacy signals; so stars are best read beside a measure customers don’t choose to enter, such as the ombud’s figures.3
The ombud’s resolved ratio
The National Financial Ombud publishes, for its 25 largest non-life participants, how many complaints it closed and how many ended with some benefit to the policyholder. A low ratio means the insurer’s original decision usually stood. The figures cover all non-life cover, not car insurance alone, and a row belongs to a licence, so a brand underwritten by another insurer shares that insurer’s row.2
The CE Index
The 2025 CE Index scored short-term insurers on customer experience; Auto & General came first overall with 73.7, and the report also names leaders on single measures, such as problem resolution and the broker channel. It covered ten insurers, and MoneyMarketing’s report names a place or a leading score for only some of them, so a dash in the table means the report gives no figure for that insurer. The same report counts Discovery Insure and MiWay among the broker-led insurers.3
The claims line
Save the number before you need it. Most insurers take claims on the same line as sales; a few, such as Naked, take them in the app, and Budget asks clients to log in.7,21
Car insurance companies by how they sell
How an insurer sells decides who you deal with. A direct insurer quotes and services you itself; a broker compares several insurers for you and stays between you and the insurer; a bank’s insurer often quotes its own clients first. The groups below follow the “How it sells” column in the table. Jump to a group:
Direct insurers
These sell to you themselves, online, by phone or in an app, without a broker. Several share an owner: Telesure owns Auto & General, Budget, Dial Direct and First for Women.31
Getting a quote. A direct insurer quotes you itself, but what its online price means differs. Naked calls the price on its site your final quote and lets you buy there and then; Pineapple says its final quote takes 90 seconds; and Auto & General lets you accept a quote and finalise the policy online.32,33,34 Others turn the form into a phone call: OUTsurance takes your details and an adviser rings back with the premium, and King Price uses call-back forms or a call or WhatsApp on 0860 50 50 50.18,35 Dotsure says buying online earns a 20% lifetime discount, iWYZE quotes online, by phone or on WhatsApp, and Discovery Insure quotes online, on 0860 000 628 or through your financial adviser.11,12,36 Auto & General’s form asks for your ID number, your car’s make and model and the address where it stays overnight, so have those to hand.34
Making a claim. You claim from the insurer itself, on the claims line in the table above. Some add their own routes: Naked handles claims in its app, MiWay takes them by phone, in its app or on WhatsApp, Momentum by phone or in its app, and Pineapple by phone, by email or on WhatsApp.20,21,25,37 Budget is the exception: its contact page lists no separate claims number, and clients log in instead.7 Several keep a 24-hour emergency line apart from claims, such as Dialdirect’s 0860 911 911 and 1st for Women’s 0860 10 42 12, so save both numbers.4,8
- 1st for Women review 1st for Women reviews and ratings
- Auto & General review Auto & General reviews and ratings
- Budget Insurance review Budget reviews and ratings
- Dial Direct review Dial Direct reviews and ratings
- Discovery Insure review
- Dotsure review Dotsure reviews and ratings
- iWYZE review iWYZE reviews and ratings
- King Price review King Price reviews and ratings
- MiWay review MiWay reviews and ratings
- Momentum Insure review Momentum Insure reviews and ratings
- Naked review
- Old Mutual Insure review Old Mutual Insure reviews and ratings
- OUTsurance review OUTsurance reviews and ratings
- Pineapple review Pineapple reviews and ratings
- Santam review Santam reviews and ratings
- Virseker review Virseker reviews and ratings
Brokers and advisers
Hollard sells its car insurance through brokers, advisers and the brands it underwrites rather than direct.16
Getting a quote and claiming. Hollard’s car insurance page doesn’t quote you itself: it sends you to brokers, advisers and partners, and points to Dotsure and Naked, two brands it is behind.16 Hollard is a shareholder in Dotsure, a separately licensed insurer, and Naked’s cover is underwritten by Hollard Specialist Insurance.16,32 At claim time Hollard’s contact page sends car customers to Dotsure, and Standard Bank lists a Hollard claims line, 0860 000 351.15,38 Other insurers on this page can also be bought through an adviser: Discovery Insure gives your financial adviser as one way to quote.11
Banks’ insurers
Each of the four big banks has its own insurer, sold to the bank’s clients and others.
Getting a quote and claiming. Each bank quotes its own way. Absa sells Activate online or on 0860 222 762, and through idirect an agent calls you back; FNB quotes on the FNB App or on 087 312 0001; Nedbank asks you to request a call-back on its vehicle insurance page; and Standard Bank has an online quote form, while its broker arm, Standard Bank Insurance Brokers, offers to find you quotes.13,22,38,39,40 A claim goes to the bank’s insurer on its own line: Absa’s short-term claims on 0860 100 876, FNB’s on 087 312 0001 or by email, Nedbank’s on 0800 333 111 and Standard Insurance’s on 0860 123 444.5,13,22,29
Choosing between car insurance companies
The service measures on this page tell you how an insurer treats people once they are clients. They don’t tell you what it will charge you, and no rating replaces a quote for your own car and cover. A sensible order:
- Narrow by how you want to buy. If you want to deal with the insurer yourself, look at the direct insurers; if you want someone to compare for you and stay with you at claim time, use a broker.
- Check the service measures for the ones you’re weighing. Look at Hellopeter’s rank and the number of reviews behind it, then the ombud’s ratio for the licence that carries the cover.1,2
- Compare quotes on the same cover. Ask each for the same excess and extras, so the cheaper quote isn’t simply less cover. You can compare car insurance quotes from the insurers side by side.
- Read the review for your shortlist. Each insurer has its own review page, and ten have a reviews page with their Hellopeter topic scores.