Car marketplaces · Compared
WeBuyCars vs AutoTrader vs Cars.co.za vs Weelee, Carfind, Automark and Auto Mart: where to buy or sell a car
Seven names come up when South Africans buy or sell a used car, and they do different jobs. WeBuyCars and Weelee buy your car and sell their own stock; AutoTrader, Cars.co.za, Carfind and Auto Mart list cars that dealers and private sellers advertise; and Automark is Toyota’s certified pre-owned network, sold through Toyota dealers. Below: what each one costs a seller, how many cars it shows, its ratings and what it offers on insurance and warranties, all as each publishes it.
This is OneCompare’s comparison of seven car marketplaces South Africans use to buy or sell a used car (also searched as webuycars vs autotrader, autotrader vs cars.co.za or weelee vs webuycars). Figures as at 17 November 2026.
The seven car marketplaces side by side
Stock counts move every day and ratings move every week, so every figure is as at the date shown.
| Marketplace | What it is | Cars shown | Cost to sell | Rating | Android app | Insurance at the sale | Warranty or returns | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WeBuyCars | Buys cars and sells its own stock1 | About 12 700 vehicles2 | No listing fee: it makes the offer at a branch or buying pod3 | 4.8 on Hellopeter, 16 913 reviews in 12 months4 | 4.5 from 3 773 reviews5 | An OUTsurance quote at the branch6 | Warranties on Category A cars; a Category A car with an undisclosed defect can be returned within six months7,8 | 087 057 00009 |
| AutoTrader | Lists dealers’ and private cars10 | 98 028 cars11 | A private ad for less than R20 a day, or an instant dealer offer12 | 4.3 on Hellopeter, 40 reviews in 12 months13 | 4.7 from 23 931 reviews14 | None: a guide to cover, no insurer named15 | From the dealer who sells the car, not from AutoTrader16 | 0860 60 50 5010 |
| Cars.co.za | Lists dealers’ and private cars17 | 78 000+ new and used18 | Featured ad R441 (14 days) or Featured Plus R645 (30 days); a free dealer offer17 | 4.8 on Google, 3 355 reviews19 | 4.7 from 5 914 reviews20 | Quotes in MyCars; no insurer named21 | From the dealer or seller: Cars.co.za isn’t a party to the sale22 | 011 450 245023 |
| Weelee | Buys cars and sells its own stock, from Centurion24 | 1 040 cars at Centurion25 | Free valuation; pre-approved dealers make offers24,26 | 4.4 on Google, 2 507 reviews; 4.3 on Hellopeter, 700 reviews27,28 | No app on Google Play29 | Auto & General, Budget and Dial Direct, through a call-me-back form30 | A returns policy under the Consumer Protection Act; motor warranties sold as add-ons30,31 | 0861 933 53332 |
| Carfind | Lists dealers’ cars, and private ads33,34 | About 37 750 vehicles (our count of its pages)33 | R160 (5 days) to R540 (40 days) for a car34 | 4.3 on Google, 103 reviews35 | 3.1 from 154 reviews36 | None: Carfind names no insurer37 | None from Carfind: its terms give no warranties on the cars listed38 | 011 561 860035 |
| Automark | Toyota’s certified pre-owned network, at Toyota dealers39 | 4 073 certified vehicles40 | A dealer offer through its valuation form, or a trade-in41 | 4.7 from 1 200 reviews, Automark’s own published score40 | No Automark app; Toyota’s MyToyota app is 3.142 | Toyota sells MyToyota Insurance; it isn’t tied to the purchase43 | Toyota Certified: complimentary 1 year / 50 000 km39 | No head-office line: call the dealer44 |
| Auto Mart | Classifieds for dealers and private sellers45 | 28 406 cars46 | Up to three free ads for a private seller47 | 4.0 on Google, 33 reviews48 | No app on Google Play49 | A King Price quote form50 | From the seller; a private sale usually has none51 | 012 342 384045 |
Ratings are on different platforms (Hellopeter, Google, Automark’s own published score), so they don’t compare one to one. Carfind publishes no stock total: the figure is our count of its results pages.
Selling your car: an offer today, or a private ad
There are two ways to sell through these sites. The quick way is an offer: WeBuyCars buys at its branches and buying pods and, once you accept, says it pays you immediately1; Weelee’s pre-approved dealers make offers on your car alongside its own buyers26; AutoTrader’s instant offer collects bids from its verified dealers12; Cars.co.za’s Sell Car Instantly asks dealers for an offer, free17; and Automark’s valuation form passes your car to a Toyota dealer, who comes back with an offer.41
The slower way is a private ad, where you set the price and deal with buyers yourself. What an ad costs, as each site publishes it:
| Site | Price of an ad |
|---|---|
| Auto Mart | Up to three free ads47 |
| AutoTrader | Less than R20 a day, in AutoTrader’s words12 |
| Carfind | R160 for 5 days, R280 for 14, R420 for 25, R540 for 4034 |
| Cars.co.za | R441 for a 14-day Featured ad, R645 for a 30-day Featured Plus ad17 |
An offer is an estimate until the car is inspected; an ad price buys exposure, not a sale.
An offer is quick and the buyer handles the paperwork; a private sale can fetch more, but you meet the buyers, check their payment has cleared and register the change of ownership yourself.
Buying: where the cars come from, the checks and the warranty
Who sells you the car decides what you can ask of them. WeBuyCars sells its own cars as Category A or Category B, with a condition report on every one1,52; Weelee sells its own cars, each with an independent condition report graded Platinum, Gold or Green53; and an Automark car has been through the dealer’s certified checks, with its year, model and mileage guaranteed.39
On AutoTrader, Cars.co.za, Carfind and Auto Mart the seller is the dealer or private person who placed the ad, and the site itself gives no warranty.16,38 A dealer is bound by the Consumer Protection Act; a private seller usually gives no warranty, and you have fewer rights.51 The checks are then yours: see how to buy safely from a listing.
WeBuyCars vs Weelee
They are different companies. WeBuyCars has been listed on the JSE since 11 April 202454; Weelee (Pty) Ltd names no owner.55 WeBuyCars has 22 branches and its buying pods56; Weelee has one store, in Centurion, and four buying pods in Gauteng.32 Selling, WeBuyCars makes you an offer itself, while Weelee puts your car in front of dealers who bid. Both also sell cars by online auction.1,57 Ratings, scams and returns for each are on WeBuyCars reviews and Weelee reviews.
AutoTrader vs Cars.co.za
Both list cars from dealers and private sellers, and both let a seller choose a paid ad or a dealer offer. AutoTrader started in 1992, as a print business58; Cars.co.za was founded in Johannesburg in 2009.59 On 17 November 2026 AutoTrader showed 98 028 cars and Cars.co.za more than 78 000, and both apps were rated 4.7 on Google Play. Reviews and scam advice for each: AutoTrader reviews and Cars.co.za reviews.
WeBuyCars vs AutoTrader
Buy from WeBuyCars and WeBuyCars is the seller, with its fees in its terms of sale: an admin and documentation fee of R2 400, or R1 500 under a R20 000 price, on a car under 3.5 tons.60 Buy through AutoTrader and the seller is the dealer or person who placed the ad, so their terms apply. Selling, WeBuyCars makes one offer; AutoTrader gives you the choice of an ad or dealer bids.
Automark vs WeBuyCars
Automark sells Toyota-certified used cars at Toyota dealers, with a complimentary 1-year / 50 000 km warranty on Toyota Certified cars.39 WeBuyCars sells every make; warranties are available on its Category A cars, and a car it licenses for you, or a bank finances, without a manufacturer warranty needs a mechanical warranty of at least 12 months.60 See Automark reviews and the warranty.
Things to know before you drive off
Insure the car before you drive it away
The car is yours, and your risk, the moment you pay, so arrange cover first. Some of these marketplaces point you to an insurer at the sale: WeBuyCars passes your details to OUTsurance for a quote6, Weelee names Auto & General, Budget and Dial Direct30, and Auto Mart’s insurance page is a King Price quote form.50 Each is one insurer’s price; you can compare quotes for the same car first.
A financed car needs comprehensive cover
A bank that finances the car will want it comprehensively insured until the loan is paid: see insuring a financed car.
The three kinds of cover
- Comprehensive cover pays for damage to your own car, theft and hijacking, as well as the damage you do to others.
- Third party, fire and theft pays if your car is stolen or burns, and for damage you do to others, but not for crash damage to your own car.
- Third party only covers the damage you cause to other people’s cars and property, and nothing on your own.
Get the quote before you agree a price
Insurance can be a large monthly cost, and it changes with the driver, the model and where the car sleeps (see what affects a car insurance premium). Two cars at the same price can cost very different amounts to insure, so get a quote on the exact car before you agree the deal.
Service plan vs maintenance plan vs warranty
Dealers and marketplaces sell three products that are easy to mix up, and none of them is insurance. As Right to Repair South Africa’s CEO explained them to BusinessTech:61
| Product | What it pays for | What it doesn’t |
|---|---|---|
| Warranty | Parts that fail prematurely with no outside cause: engine and turbo, fuel system, drive shafts and axles, brakes61 | Failures caused by outside factors, such as an accident |
| Service plan | The parts and labour of the services in the maker’s schedule: oils, filters, spark plugs61 | Work caused by modifications, accidents or misuse |
| Maintenance plan | A service plan plus repairs and parts outside a regular service, usually with labour61 | Cover varies by maker: check the plan with the dealer61 |
| Car insurance | Depends on the cover: see comprehensive, third party, fire and theft and third party only | Servicing, which the plans above cover |
Under the competition guidelines a buyer may buy a service plan separately, or decline it.61
The marketplaces sell these too. With finance, WeBuyCars offers warranties, comprehensive insurance, and service and maintenance plans1; Weelee offers motor warranties and service plans as add-ons30; and Cars.co.za’s MyCars offers service quotes and wear and tear plans.21
What to check when buying a used car
Carfind’s own seven steps, with what the other sites add:
- Set a budget that includes fuel, insurance and maintenance, not only the price.62
- Research the model, then check the car’s history report.62
- Inspect the car, and have a mechanic inspect it before you pay.62
- Verify that the seller owns the car, and only then negotiate the price.62
- Read the condition report where the seller gives one: WeBuyCars and Weelee publish one on every car they sell.52,53
- Check the price against the market: AutoTrader warns that a price too good to be true is where most frauds start, and to ask the seller for a landline.16
More, with the scams to watch for: buying safely from a listing.
Each marketplace in full
| Marketplace | Contact numbers, branches and how it works | Reviews, ratings and warranty |
|---|---|---|
| WeBuyCars | WeBuyCars contact numbers | WeBuyCars reviews |
| AutoTrader | AutoTrader contact numbers | AutoTrader reviews |
| Cars.co.za | Cars.co.za contact numbers | Cars.co.za reviews |
| Weelee | Weelee contact numbers | Weelee reviews |
| Carfind | Carfind contact numbers | Carfind reviews |
| Automark | Automark contact numbers | Automark reviews |
| Auto Mart | Auto Mart contact numbers | Auto Mart reviews |