Insurer review · Old Mutual Insure
Old Mutual insurance: Old Mutual car insurance, contact numbers and tracker requirements
Old Mutual's car insurance contact number is 0860 22 55 63 for direct customers, and its claims line is 0861 24 7 365. Old Mutual car insurance is underwritten by Old Mutual Insure Ltd, formerly Mutual & Federal (renamed Old Mutual Insure in 2017), a licensed non-life insurer (FSP 12), and sold direct and through brokers. Old Mutual Insure publishes its tracker rules: on its brokered products a car worth R500,000 or more needs a tracker, a car worth R1.5 million or more needs an early-warning tracker, and a list of high-theft models needs one whatever its value. Without the required device, depending on the product, you pay a higher excess or lose theft cover.
Contact details, cover and benefits checked on 15 November 2026 against Old Mutual's car insurance page. Tracker rules and terms checked on 3 November 2026 against Old Mutual Insure's July 2026 tracker communication to brokers, Old Mutual's car insurance page and terms, iWYZE's site, the Prudential Authority and FSCA registers, the National Financial Ombud Scheme's 2025 figures and Hellopeter.
| What | Details |
|---|---|
| Direct customers: quotes and information | 0860 22 55 63 |
| Claims | 0861 24 7 365 |
| Emergency assistance | 0860 24 7 365 |
| Brokers and advisers | 0860 63 73 73 |
| Insurer | Old Mutual Insure Ltd, FSP 12 |
| Formerly | Mutual & Federal (renamed Old Mutual Insure in 2017) |
| Direct brand | iWYZE, also underwritten by Old Mutual Insure |
Contact lines: Old Mutual Insure’s published information as at 15 November 2026.1 Insurer and licence: the Prudential Authority’s list of insurers and the FSCA’s FSP register.2,3 This is general information only: naming Old Mutual Insure here does not mean it endorses or partners with OneCompare. Confirm current details with the insurer before you rely on them.
Old Mutual insurance: Old Mutual Insure, iWYZE and Mutual & Federal
Old Mutual car insurance and iWYZE come from the same insurer, Old Mutual Insure, which is why they are often found together: Old Mutual sells its car cover, motorsure, direct and through brokers, and iWYZE is Old Mutual's direct brand, with its own page in our reviews, iWYZE car insurance. Old Mutual Insure Ltd is on the Prudential Authority's list of licensed non-life insurers (PA0000173) and on the FSCA's register as FSP 12. Old Mutual's car insurance terms say: "Old Mutual Car Insurance is underwritten by Old Mutual Insure Limited." Old Mutual says Old Mutual Insure has a track record of 180 years.2,3,4,5
If you remember Mutual & Federal, it is the same company: Mutual & Federal was renamed Old Mutual Insure in June 2017. iWYZE's footer, too, says it is underwritten by Old Mutual Insure.6,7
How much is Old Mutual car insurance per month?
Old Mutual's car insurance page, read on 15 November 2026, gives no monthly price: it describes its premiums only as affordable and offers a quote online, on 0860 22 55 63 for direct customers, or through a broker or adviser on 0860 63 73 73.1
Before you take an Old Mutual Insure quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.
Compare quotesOld Mutual car insurance cover
Old Mutual's car insurance page lists comprehensive cover, which "covers just about everything - theft, hijacking, fire, accidents, natural events, and liability to a third party's vehicle or property", third party, fire and theft, and third party only. It calls its car product motorsure.
The page also explains when the cheaper cover is available: "If there is no loan or credit agreement on the vehicle, you have the option to take out Third Party, Fire and Theft insurance… or Third Party Only."5
Before you take an Old Mutual Insure quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.
Compare quotesOld Mutual car insurance benefits
Old Mutual lists what its motorsure car insurance offers: a seamless claims process, comprehensive cover for your car, affordable premiums, optional 24-hour emergency roadside assistance, optional car hire, and a choice of three types of cover. It also says there are no waiting periods when you claim: you can claim as soon as you have an accident or the car is stolen or hijacked.1
For a car you are keeping longer, Old Mutual sells Value4U Motor VAPS alongside the policy: extended warranty, scratch and dent cover, and tyre and rim cover, for everyday damage and mechanical breakdowns.1
Old Mutual Insure tracker requirements
Old Mutual Insure is one of the few insurers that publishes its rules. Its communication to brokers of 16 July 2026, "Reaffirming our vehicle tracking device and recovery system requirements", sets them by product, by car value and by model. They apply to its brokered products: Allsure, Elite, Motorsure and Justwheels for private cars, and Multisure and its other commercial products.
The minimum device is an automatically activated, early-warning recovery unit linked to a 24-hour control centre and a recovery service, one that "is always armed when the vehicle is parked and switched off", so you don't have to phone anyone when the car is stolen. A newly insured car has 14 days to have the device fitted, after which theft and hijacking cover is excluded until it is; existing clients have until renewal. Compulsory tracking does not apply to cars based in the Western, Eastern and Northern Cape, Botswana and Namibia.
Old Mutual Insure names the brands it approves: Matrix, Powerfleet Beame (including Beame Plus 100), C-Track, Netstar, Tracker, Cartrack, Bandit, Bidtrack, Selftrack, My Tracer, Autotrak, Mobify/Tracker, Digit, Mtrack, Smartrak and Tracetec, and any other early-warning solution that meets its minimum. It reviews its high-theft list twice a year; the current one is version 01.2026.8
| Product and car | What is required | Without it |
|---|---|---|
| Allsure, R500,000 to R1,499,999 | A tracking device | Additional excess of 5%, minimum R2,750 |
| Elite, R500,000 to R1,499,999 | A tracking device | Additional excess of 10% of the claim, minimum R15,000 |
| Allsure and Elite, R1.5 million and above | An early-warning tracker | No theft cover |
| Motorsure and Justwheels: any Hilux, Fortuner, Isuzu or Mazda Drifter; any Toyota or VW over R150,000; any car R500,000 to R1,499,999 | A tracking device | No theft cover |
| Commercial products, R750,000 and above | An automatically activated recovery device with 24-hour monitoring | Theft and hijacking cover depends on it |
| High-theft list, all products | An approved early-warning tracker | Mandatory; no separate penalty stated |
Before you take an Old Mutual Insure quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.
Compare quotesWhich cars are on Old Mutual Insure’s high-theft list?
The July 2026 list, for all products, names the Ford Ranger (from the 2007 model), Hyundai H100, Isuzu KB300 and D-Max, Kia K2500 and K2700, Nissan NP200, Toyota Hilux, VW Polo, Toyota Fortuner, Toyota Land Cruiser, Toyota Prado (from the 2017 model), Toyota Etios and Verso, Toyota Cross and Toyota Quantum. Approved early-warning trackers "remain mandatory" for these across its personal and commercial lines.
If your car is on the list or above a value band and you buy through a broker, ask which product you are on and what your schedule says before cover starts, and book the fitment inside the 14 days. Old Mutual's direct car terms we read don't contain a tracker clause, so a direct client's requirement is the one on the schedule.4,8
How do I claim from Old Mutual car insurance?
Call Old Mutual's claims line on 0861 24 7 365, or use its claims page; for emergency assistance the number is 0860 24 7 365. Old Mutual says you must report the claim to the police and give the insurer all the information and documents it asks for.1
How do I cancel Old Mutual car insurance?
By phone or in writing: Old Mutual's car terms let you cancel either way, effective at midnight that day, and Old Mutual gives 31 days' written notice when it cancels. No premium is refunded for a cancellation with less than 31 days' notice where the premium was already collected.4
The car terms we read are Old Mutual Car Insurance's general terms from September 2021, served from an iWYZE address, so check them against your own policy. They say Old Mutual tries again 15 days after a missed premium and you have no cover for that period if it can't collect; if the next debit also fails, the policy is cancelled from the first missed date. A stop payment cancels the policy, and if the first premium is never paid the policy is cancelled from the start.4
If a claim is rejected you have 90 days to object; the 2021 terms name the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance, which the National Financial Ombud Scheme replaced on 1 March 2024.4,9
Old Mutual Insure reviews and complaints
In the National Financial Ombud Scheme's 2025 table of its 25 largest non-life participants, Old Mutual Insure had 634 formal complaints opened, 816 closed and 84 finalised with some benefit to the client, a resolved ratio of 10%. The table covers every line of business, personal and commercial, and counts complaints rather than rates per policy, so a bigger insurer shows more of them.10
On Hellopeter on 2 November 2026, Old Mutual Insure was fourth in the Car Insurance category, with 4.8 stars and a TrustIndex of 10 from about 3,517 reviews in the last 12 months.11
The OneCompare view
Old Mutual Insure is unusually open about trackers: value bands, a named high-theft list, approved brands and a 14-day deadline, with a regional exemption for the Cape provinces. If your car is on that list or above R500,000, know which product you are on and fit the device in time. Its direct car terms are dated 2021, so ask for the current wording.