OneCompare

Insurer reviews · 1st for Women

Is 1st for Women a good insurer? Reviews, ratings and complaints

Yes, by its ratings: 1st for Women has 4.6 stars from 6,148 Hellopeter reviews in the past year and came fourth in the 2025 CE Index. Its consultants and pricing are rated above the industry; claims handling (2.7) and repairs (2.2) are rated below it, and its 2025 ombud ratio was 9%.

Checked on 11 November 2026 against Hellopeter, Google Play, the App Store, the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 annual report, the 2025 CE Index reports and 1st for Women’s own pages.

1st for Women car insurance: cover, excess and contact

Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email and SMS.

1st for Women ratings at a glance

1st for Women ratings at a glance (Hellopeter and app stores seen 11 November 2026)
MeasureResult
Hellopeter stars4.6 out of 5, from 6,148 reviews in the last 12 months1
Hellopeter TrustIndex10 out of 101
Reviews on Hellopeter, all time24,9171
Hellopeter NPS421
Average reply time (all / negative reviews)30 min / 33 min1
Negative reviews replied to99%1
Hellopeter rank#14 in Insurance, #12 in Car Insurance1
Google Play4.4 from 7,411 ratings (1st for Women App)2
App Store (South Africa)4.3 from 1,432 ratings (1st for Women App)3
Ombud resolved ratio (2025 report)9% (First for Women Insurance Company Ltd); non-life division 11%4
CE Index 2025 (reported early 2026)4th overall5,6

Hellopeter’s figures change daily; its TrustIndex mixes star ratings with how quickly a business replies. The ombud ratio is complaints decided with some benefit to the client, divided by complaints closed. These ratings are other sites’ figures, not OneCompare’s, and naming 1st for Women here doesn’t mean it endorses or partners with us.

What 1st for Women clients praise

In Hellopeter’s score table 1st for Women does best on Agent Quality, 4.3 where the industry sits at 4.1, and on Pricing & Premiums, 3.7 where the industry sits at 2.7. Communication is 3.3, a little above the industry’s 3.0.1

Hellopeter’s summary of the positive reviews describes patient consultants who speak the client’s language and call back when they say they will, and premiums that came down after a policy review. The insurer’s Net Promoter Score on Hellopeter is 42.1

What 1st for Women clients complain about

Claims Handling, at 2.7, and Repair Quality, at 2.2, are both under the industry’s 2.9; the repair score is level with iWYZE’s, and of the fifteen insurers here only Absa Insurance scores lower. Complaints describe claims that take too long, rejections without a clear reason, excess recovery from the other driver’s insurer that stalls, disputes over courtesy cars and car hire, and the work of panel beaters.1

1st for Women answers its Hellopeter reviewers in 30 minutes on average and negative reviews in 33 minutes, and has replied to 99% of the negative ones. Its total on Hellopeter is 24,917 reviews.1

Before you take a 1st for Women quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.

Compare quotes

1st for Women ombud complaints (NFO 2025)

First for Women Insurance Company Ltd had 122 complaints registered with the National Financial Ombud Scheme in 2025 and 115 opened as formal complaints. Of the 127 it closed, 11 were finalised with some benefit to the client, giving a resolved ratio of 9%.4

Its counts are smaller than the bigger insurers’, but counts are not per policy. The ratio is the measure to compare: 9% is higher than the other Telesure brands in the table, Budget and Auto & General at 4% each, and lower than the division’s 11%.4

1st for Women awards and its own claims

The University of Pretoria’s 2025 Customer Experience Index for short-term insurance, compiled by Prof. Adré Schreuder from 6,384 consumers, placed 1st for Women fourth overall, behind Auto & General, the Budget and Virseker pair, and Dialdirect.5,6

On its own site 1st for Women says it was named Top Short-Term Insurer in the ASK AFRICA Orange Index 2026/2027, that it is on Forbes and Statista’s World’s Best Insurance Companies list for 2023 to 2026, and that clients rate its service 9.2 out of 10 in its own internal surveys after service calls. Those are its claims; the 9.2 is its own measure.7

Who is First for Women underwritten by?

By itself: First for Women Insurance Company Ltd is a licensed insurer and authorised financial services provider, FSP 15261, so it carries its own policies rather than selling another insurer’s. It sits in the Telesure Investment Holdings group, whose May 2026 PAIA manual names TIH as the holding company of First for Women, Auto & General, Budget and Dial Direct.8,9

How 1st for Women compares with 14 other insurers

People also ask which car insurer is best for women in South Africa. No published measure ranks insurers for women drivers, so the table below gives the figures that do exist, Hellopeter scores and ombud ratios, for fifteen insurers side by side.

Fifteen car insurers on Hellopeter and at the ombud (Hellopeter seen 11 November 2026 for the first ten; 16 November 2026 for Santam, Old Mutual Insure, Momentum Insure, Absa Insurance and Virseker)
InsurerHellopeter starsClaims HandlingRepair QualityPricing & PremiumsOmbud resolved ratio 2025
Dial Direct4.73.12.53.4Not in the top 25
Budget Insurance4.73.02.53.54%
Auto & General4.63.32.84.14%
Pineapple4.62.62.33.217% (underwriter, all brands)
1st for Women4.62.72.23.79%
OUTsurance4.84.13.93.83%
iWYZE4.63.22.23.510% (underwriter, all brands)
MiWay4.83.74.23.85%
King Price4.83.83.73.94%
Dotsure4.83.82.53.47%
Santam4.83.32.64.17%
Old Mutual Insure4.83.5–3.910%
Momentum Insure4.63.32.63.811%
Absa Insurance4.51.91.63.413%
Virseker4.63.12.43.44% (underwriter, all brands)
Industry figure–2.92.92.711% (non-life division)

Stars and topic scores from each insurer’s Hellopeter profile and score table, seen 11 November 2026 for the first ten and 16 November 2026 for the last five; the industry figure is Hellopeter’s for insurance. Ombud ratios from the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 table of its 25 largest non-life participants, where a row is the licence, so an underwriter’s row covers every brand it carries.1,4,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23

More insurer reviews: Budget Insurance reviews, Dial Direct reviews, Auto & General reviews, Pineapple reviews, OUTsurance reviews, iWYZE reviews, MiWay reviews, King Price reviews, Dotsure reviews, Santam reviews, Old Mutual Insure reviews, Momentum Insure reviews, Absa Insurance reviews, Virseker reviews.

Before you buy 1st for Women: what to check

Ask what courtesy car or car hire your policy includes, for how many days, and whether it depends on the claim being accepted first, as those disputes recur in the reviews. If the other driver caused the accident, ask how 1st for Women recovers your excess and how you will hear when it has.

When a claim is declined, ask for the reason and the policy clause in writing; you can escalate inside the insurer and then to the ombud at no cost. Compare the premium with other insurers on matching cover and excess, including its Telesure sister brands.

Compare your 1st for Women premium

Already with 1st for Women or have a 1st for Women quote? Send it to us on WhatsApp and we’ll get you comparison quotes from other insurers.

Get quotes compared on WhatsApp →
OneCompare (Pty) Ltd is an authorised financial services provider (FSP 55551). We are not First for Women Insurance Company Ltd and don’t act for it. By messaging us you agree that we may use your details to get you quotes, in line with POPIA and our privacy policy.
Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email and SMS.

Compare car insurance quotes from every insurer →

Questions about 1st for Women reviews

On 11 November 2026 it had 4.6 stars and a TrustIndex of 10 on Hellopeter, and it was fourth in the 2025 CE Index. Its ombud resolved ratio for 2025 was 9%.

First for Women Insurance Company Ltd underwrites its own policies under its own licence (FSP 15261). It is part of the Telesure Investment Holdings group.

No published ranking measures that. The comparison table on this page sets out the Hellopeter scores and ombud ratios that do exist for fifteen insurers, so you can weigh them yourself.

Hellopeter scores its claims handling at 2.7 against an industry 2.9. Reviewers raise delays, unexplained rejections and stalled excess recovery, and praise patient consultants.

4.4 on Google Play from 7,411 ratings and 4.3 on the App Store from 1,432, seen on 11 November 2026.

In about 33 minutes for negative reviews, and it has replied to 99% of them.

Sources

  1. Hellopeter, “1st for Women reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  2. Google Play, “1st for Women App (app listing)”, seen 11 November 2026. play.google.com
  3. Apple App Store (South Africa), “1st for Women App (app listing)”, seen 11 November 2026. apps.apple.com
  4. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “Annual Report 2025 (non-life division; statistics per top 25 participants)”, 2025 calendar year, published 2026. nfosa.co.za
  5. InsuranceBiz, “Short-term insurance delivers mixed customer experience results, index shows (CE Index 2025)”, 28 January 2026. insurancebiz.co.za
  6. Moonstone, “Short-term insurers strengthen customer experience, but execution gaps persist (CE Index 2025)”, 5 February 2026. moonstone.co.za
  7. 1st for Women, “Home page (awards)”, read 11 November 2026. firstforwomen.co.za
  8. FSCA, “Authorised Financial Service Providers search”, read 2 November 2026. fsca.co.za
  9. Telesure Investment Holdings, “PAIA manual”, May 2026. tihsa.co.za
  10. Hellopeter, “Dialdirect reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  11. Hellopeter, “Budget Insurance reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  12. Hellopeter, “Auto & General reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  13. Hellopeter, “Pineapple reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  14. Hellopeter, “OUTsurance reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  15. Hellopeter, “iWYZE reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  16. Hellopeter, “MiWay reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  17. Hellopeter, “King Price reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  18. Hellopeter, “dotsure.co.za reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  19. Hellopeter, “Santam reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  20. Hellopeter, “Old Mutual Insure reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  21. Hellopeter, “Momentum Insure reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  22. Hellopeter, “Absa Insurance Company Limited reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  23. Hellopeter, “Virseker reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com

Ratings move every day. Check 1st for Women’s Hellopeter profile and the app stores for today’s figures, and confirm cover and prices with the insurer before you buy.