Buying a car
Dealership car insurance in South Africa: Toyota, VW and BMW dealer insurance, whether you must take it, and how to use your own
No. A dealer may not make you buy its insurance as a condition of selling you the car: the Consumer Protection Act bars a supplier from requiring you to buy other goods or services from it or a designated third party, with narrow exceptions.1 If the car is financed, the lender may require insurance against damage or loss of the car, but you “must be given, and be informed of, the right to waive that proposed policy and substitute a policy of the consumer’s own choice”.2
Checked on 4 November 2026 against the Consumer Protection Act, the National Credit Act, the Policyholder Protection Rules and Toyota’s and Volkswagen Financial Services’ own insurance pages. General information, not legal advice.
| Question | What the law or the carmaker says |
|---|---|
| Can a dealer make me take its insurance? | Not as a condition of the sale, unless one of the Consumer Protection Act’s exceptions applies1 |
| What may my lender require? | Insurance against damage or loss of the car, up to what you still owe, at a reasonable cost2 |
| Can I use my own insurer? | Yes: you have the right to waive the lender’s proposed policy and use your own2 |
| Will my insurer help? | It must help you meet the lender’s requirements and confirm your policy to the lender3 |
| Toyota’s own words | Customers “have the freedom of choice to obtain their own insurance”4 |
General information, not legal advice. Your finance agreement sets out what your lender requires.
Do I have to take the dealer’s insurance in South Africa?
No. Section 13 of the Consumer Protection Act says a supplier “must not require, as a condition of offering to supply or supplying any goods or services”, that you buy other goods or services from it, enter an additional agreement with it or a designated third party, or buy from a designated third party.1
The exceptions are narrow: the supplier must show that bundling is more convenient for you than the choice you lose, or that it gives you an economic benefit, or it must offer the bundled items separately at individual prices.1 Ask for the price of the car without the insurance.
Can a dealer force me to take their insurance?
Not as a condition of selling you the car. If you’re told the sale or the finance depends on the dealer’s policy, ask for it in writing and for the separate price, and point to your right to use your own insurer under the National Credit Act (below).1,2
What your car finance lender can and can’t require
Section 106 of the National Credit Act sets the rules for insurance on financed goods:
- What it may require: insurance “against damage or loss of the property” financed, “not exceeding … the total of the consumer’s outstanding obligations”.
- What it may not demand: insurance that is “unreasonable” or “at an unreasonable cost to the consumer, having regard to the actual risk”.
- Your right to choose: you must be told of “the right to waive that proposed policy and substitute a policy of the consumer’s own choice”.
- If you take the lender’s cover: it may “not add any surcharge, fee or additional premium above the actual cost of insurance”, and must disclose any fee or commission it earns on it.
- What it may still ask of your own policy: a direction to your insurer naming the lender as a loss payee up to the settlement value.2
Your own insurer has to play its part: the Policyholder Protection Rules require it to help you meet the lender’s requirements and confirm your policy to the lender on request.3
Buying a car? Compare car insurance quotes before you sign for the dealer’s.
Compare quotesDealer insurance vs your own insurance: Toyota, VW, BMW and Kia
The insurance a dealer offers is usually the carmaker’s own branded cover, sold through its finance arm and underwritten by an ordinary insurer. It can suit you, but compare it like any other quote: the same cover, excess and extras, side by side with quotes from other insurers. Here is what each carmaker’s dealers sell.
Toyota dealership insurance (MyToyota Insurance)
MyToyota Insurance is brought by Toyota Insurance Management South Africa (FSP 51394) and “provided, administered and underwritten by Auto and General Insurance Company Ltd”. On its Corolla Cross offer, running since 17 August 2026, the premium is fixed for 12 months and the anniversary increase is capped at 6%, and Toyota says customers “are not obligated to accept the specially negotiated flat rates and have the freedom of choice to obtain their own insurance”.4
To compare it, get a MyToyota quote on 0860 98 98 98; claims and general questions go to 0800 139 111. Toyota’s GAPP shortfall cover is a separate product, underwritten by Hollard.5,6 Our Toyota insurance page covers MyToyota’s cover and offers in full.
VW dealership insurance (VW Financial Services), and Audi
Volkswagen Financial Services sells VW Comprehensive, underwritten by Budget Insurance Company; you ask for a quote at a VW dealership or through its contact request form.7 For Audi, it sells Shortfall Plus cover, underwritten by Hollard.8 See our VW insurance and Audi insurance pages.
BMW dealership insurance (BMW Top Up)
The cover BMW South Africa lists for a financed BMW is Top Up (GAP) insurance: if the car is stolen or written off, it pays the difference between your comprehensive insurer’s settlement and what you still owe on finance.9 The comprehensive cover itself is yours to choose. Our BMW insurance page has the costs and tracker rules.
Kia dealership insurance (Kia deposit cover)
Kia Financial Services sells deposit cover: 10% of the sum insured, up to R100,000, toward the deposit on a replacement car when yours isn’t recovered within 31 days or is beyond economical repair.10 Like shortfall cover, it sits on top of the comprehensive policy you choose. Our Kia insurance page covers the Kia range.
Used car dealer insurance vs your own insurance
The rules are the same at a used car dealer. Section 13 of the Consumer Protection Act applies to any supplier, and section 106 of the National Credit Act to any credit agreement for the car, new or used.1,2 When you compare a dealer’s quote with your own, check whether each pays out on retail, market or trade value: our guide to retail vs market value explains the difference.
Insuring the car before you collect it
Have cover in place before you drive away, and send proof of it to the bank or dealer. Some insurers make this quick: Naked says you “can insure your new car in minutes” and send proof of cover to your bank or dealer through its app.11 The same applies to a used car from a dealer or a private seller.
On a financed car, also look at credit shortfall cover, which pays what you still owe if the car is written off for less than the loan.
Buying used rather than new? Our guides to the places South Africans buy used cars give each one’s contact numbers, branches and how its insurance works: WeBuyCars, AutoTrader, Cars.co.za, Weelee, Carfind, Automark and Auto Mart.