Insurer reviews · Old Mutual Insure
Is Old Mutual Insure a good insurer? Reviews, ratings and complaints
Mostly yes: Old Mutual Insure has 4.8 stars from 3,453 Hellopeter reviews in the past year and ranks third in Hellopeter’s Car Insurance category, with a 10% ombud resolved ratio for 2025, just under the non-life division’s 11%. Its agents score 4.5; claims are where reviewers’ frustration lies.
Checked on 16 November 2026 against Hellopeter, Google Play, the App Store, the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 annual report, MoneyMarketing’s report of the 2025 CE Index, and Old Mutual’s and iWYZE’s own pages.
Old Mutual Insure car insurance: cover, excess and contact
Old Mutual Insure at a glance
- Who carries the cover: Old Mutual Insure Ltd, formerly Mutual & Federal, which describes itself as a wholly owned subsidiary of Old Mutual Limited.1,2
- How you buy it: direct from Old Mutual, through a broker or adviser, or through iWYZE, the direct brand Old Mutual Insure also underwrites.3,4
- Hellopeter: 4.8 stars and a TrustIndex of 10 from 3,453 reviews in the last 12 months, third in Car Insurance, seen 16 November 2026.1
- Ombud: 84 of 816 complaints closed in 2025 were finalised with some benefit to the client, a resolved ratio of 10%.5
- Stand-out: Old Mutual says there are no waiting periods when you claim, and it publishes which cars need a tracker.3,6
Old Mutual Insure pros and cons
Pros
- Third in Hellopeter’s Car Insurance ranking and fifth across all insurance, with 4.8 stars and a TrustIndex of 10.1
- Agent Quality scores 4.5 (industry 4.1): Hellopeter’s summary says clients name consultants who resolve a query on the first call and follow up without being chased.1
- Pricing & Premiums scores 3.9 against an industry 2.7.1
- In the 2025 CE Index, Old Mutual Insure was one of the brands that turned more than 70% of clients’ intention to recommend it into actual recommendations.7
Cons
- Claims are the weak point in Hellopeter’s summary: assessments, underinsurance calculations and slow feedback cause the sharpest frustration, and Hellopeter shows no Repair Quality score for it.1
- Communication complaints recur: unanswered emails to claim handlers, long hold times at the call centre and being transferred repeatedly.1
- The Old Mutual App, the group’s app that its car page links to, is rated 3.5 on the App Store from 179 ratings.8
How much does Old Mutual car insurance cost?
Old Mutual doesn’t publish a car insurance price: its page lists “affordable premiums” among what its motorsure cover offers, and the figure for your car comes from a quote, as our Old Mutual car insurance page explains. Reviewers rate Old Mutual Insure’s Pricing & Premiums 3.9 on Hellopeter, against an industry 2.7.1,3
Before you take an Old Mutual Insure quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.
Compare quotesOld Mutual Insure ratings at a glance
| Measure | Result |
|---|---|
| Hellopeter stars | 4.8 out of 5, from 3,453 reviews in the last 12 months1 |
| Hellopeter TrustIndex | 10 out of 101 |
| Reviews on Hellopeter, all time | 12,4241 |
| Hellopeter NPS | 501 |
| Average reply time (all / negative reviews) | 3 h 24 min / 5 h 28 min1 |
| Negative reviews replied to | 100%1 |
| Hellopeter rank | #5 in Insurance, #3 in Car Insurance1 |
| Google Play | 4.3 from 3,856 ratings (Old Mutual, the group’s app)9 |
| App Store (South Africa) | 3.5 from 179 ratings (Old Mutual App, the group’s app)8 |
| Ombud resolved ratio (2025 report) | 10% (Old Mutual Insure Ltd); non-life division 11%5 |
| CE Index 2025 (reported early 2026) | Intention-to-action ratio above 70%, with OUTsurance7 |
Hellopeter’s figures change daily; its TrustIndex mixes star ratings with how quickly a business replies. The ombud ratio is complaints decided with some benefit to the client, divided by complaints closed. These ratings are other sites’ figures, not OneCompare’s, and naming Old Mutual Insure here doesn’t mean it endorses or partners with us.
What Old Mutual Insure clients praise
Old Mutual Insure is above the industry on the four topics Hellopeter scores for it: Agent Quality 4.5 (industry 4.1), Pricing & Premiums 3.9 (2.7), Communication 3.6 (3.0) and Claims Handling 3.5 (2.9).1
Hellopeter’s summary calls its front line unusually strong: clients name consultants in sales, retentions and payments who secure discounts and help after hours. Its Net Promoter Score on Hellopeter is 50.1
Old Mutual Insure complaints: what reviewers raise
The warmth doesn’t always reach the claims team, Hellopeter’s summary says: reviewers dispute assessments and underinsurance calculations, and describe unanswered emails to claim handlers, long hold times and being passed from one department to another.1
Old Mutual Insure replies to every negative review on Hellopeter, in 5 h 28 min on average, and to all reviews in 3 h 24 min. Hellopeter has 12,424 reviews for it in total.1
Before you take an Old Mutual Insure quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.
Compare quotesOld Mutual Insure ombud complaints (NFO 2025)
The National Financial Ombud Scheme registered 682 cases about Old Mutual Insure Ltd in 2025 and opened 634 formal complaints, 530 on personal lines and 104 on commercial. It closed 816, and 84 were finalised with some benefit to the client: a resolved ratio of 10%, just under the non-life division’s 11%.5
The row covers everything Old Mutual Insure underwrites, iWYZE included, and counts complaints rather than rates per policy.4,5
Old Mutual Insure in the CE Index, and its own claims
In the 2025 CE Index for short-term insurance, compiled at the University of Pretoria from 6,384 consumers, MoneyMarketing reports that OUTsurance and Old Mutual Insure both converted more than 70% of clients’ stated intention to recommend into actual recommendations, though their Net Promoter Scores were lower than some others’.7
Old Mutual says Old Mutual Insure has a track record of 180 years, and that there are no waiting periods when you claim. Those are Old Mutual’s own claims.3
Old Mutual Insure’s owner and licence
Old Mutual Insure Ltd is on the Prudential Authority’s list of licensed non-life insurers and on the FSCA’s register as FSP 12. On its Hellopeter profile it describes itself as a wholly owned subsidiary of Old Mutual Limited, serving personal, commercial and corporate clients.1,10,11
iWYZE is Old Mutual’s direct brand and is underwritten by Old Mutual Insure too, so the two share an insurer.4
How Old Mutual Insure compares with 14 other insurers
Against iWYZE, the direct brand on the same licence, Old Mutual Insure has more stars on Hellopeter, 4.8 to 4.6, and higher Claims Handling, 3.5 to 3.2, and Pricing & Premiums, 3.9 to 3.5. The iWYZE figures were seen on 11 November 2026.1,12
| Insurer | Hellopeter stars | Claims Handling | Repair Quality | Pricing & Premiums | Ombud resolved ratio 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dial Direct | 4.7 | 3.1 | 2.5 | 3.4 | Not in the top 25 |
| Budget Insurance | 4.7 | 3.0 | 2.5 | 3.5 | 4% |
| Auto & General | 4.6 | 3.3 | 2.8 | 4.1 | 4% |
| Pineapple | 4.6 | 2.6 | 2.3 | 3.2 | 17% (underwriter, all brands) |
| 1st for Women | 4.6 | 2.7 | 2.2 | 3.7 | 9% |
| OUTsurance | 4.8 | 4.1 | 3.9 | 3.8 | 3% |
| iWYZE | 4.6 | 3.2 | 2.2 | 3.5 | 10% (underwriter, all brands) |
| MiWay | 4.8 | 3.7 | 4.2 | 3.8 | 5% |
| King Price | 4.8 | 3.8 | 3.7 | 3.9 | 4% |
| Dotsure | 4.8 | 3.8 | 2.5 | 3.4 | 7% |
| Santam | 4.8 | 3.3 | 2.6 | 4.1 | 7% |
| Old Mutual Insure | 4.8 | 3.5 | – | 3.9 | 10% |
| Momentum Insure | 4.6 | 3.3 | 2.6 | 3.8 | 11% |
| Absa Insurance | 4.5 | 1.9 | 1.6 | 3.4 | 13% |
| Virseker | 4.6 | 3.1 | 2.4 | 3.4 | 4% (underwriter, all brands) |
| Industry figure | – | 2.9 | 2.9 | 2.7 | 11% (non-life division) |
Stars and topic scores from each insurer’s Hellopeter profile and score table, seen 11 November 2026 for the first ten and 16 November 2026 for the last five; the industry figure is Hellopeter’s for insurance. Ombud ratios from the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 table of its 25 largest non-life participants, where a row is the licence, so an underwriter’s row covers every brand it carries.1,5,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25
More insurer reviews: Budget Insurance reviews, Dial Direct reviews, Auto & General reviews, Pineapple reviews, 1st for Women reviews, OUTsurance reviews, iWYZE reviews, MiWay reviews, King Price reviews, Dotsure reviews, Santam reviews, Momentum Insure reviews, Absa Insurance reviews, Virseker reviews.
Before you buy Old Mutual Insure: what to check
Check that every item is insured for what it would cost to replace today, since underinsurance calculations are among the claims reviewers dispute. If your car is on Old Mutual Insure’s high-theft list or above its value bands, fit the tracker it asks for in time.
If you claim, ask who your handler is and how to reach them directly, and put follow-ups in writing. Compare the quote with iWYZE’s and with insurers outside the group on the same cover and excess.
Compare your Old Mutual Insure premium
Already with Old Mutual Insure or have an Old Mutual Insure quote? Send it to us on WhatsApp and we’ll get you comparison quotes from other insurers.
Get quotes compared on WhatsApp →