OneCompare

Car insurance claims

Why car insurance claims get declined in South Africa: the ten reasons, the real cases, and how to protect yours

Get your policy checked →Upload your schedule for a free written review.

The most common reason a car insurance claim is rejected is an exclusion in the policy. In 2025 the leading one at the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO) was driving under the influence of alcohol, up 67% on 2024; it overtook a lack of due care, and misrepresentation or non-disclosure when the policy was taken out was the other common one.1 Motor insurance made up 35.4% of the complaints the ombud finalised, and it changed the outcome in 11% of non-life complaints. Almost every reason below is set out in your policy wording before you ever claim.

Figures from the NFO’s Annual Report 2025, rules from the Policyholder Protection Rules, and conditions quoted from insurers’ own policy wordings; cases from the ombuds’ and courts’ published decisions or the trade press that reported them. Checked 2 November 2026. General information, not advice: your policy wording and schedule decide your cover.

The ten reasons car insurance claims get declined
ReasonWhat the ombud or the wording saysHow to protect your claim
1. Driving under the influenceThe leading exclusion in rejected motor claims the ombud saw in 20251Don’t drive after drinking, and never refuse a breath or blood test
2. Lack of due care or recklessnessThe leading rejection reason in 2024, overtaken by drunk driving in 20251Lock up, keep keys safe, and act at once after a loss
3. Non-disclosure or misrepresentationAnother prevalent exclusion, “at the inception of the policy”1Declare past incidents, modifications, the real driver and where the car sleeps
4. Driver not licensed or not allowedExcluded in the wordings read: no valid licence, or an endorsed one2,3,4Keep the licence valid and the regular driver on the schedule correct
5. Business or e-hailing use not declaredEvery personal wording read excludes fare-paying passengers5Tell the insurer, and buy e-hailing cover for Uber or Bolt
6. Tracker missing, wrong or not workingSome wordings remove theft and hijack cover outright4Fit the device your schedule names, keep it paid, and test it
7. Premium not paidInsurers read give a 15-day grace period from the second month2,5Fix a bounced debit order inside the grace period
8. Reported too latePolice within 24 hours and the insurer within 30 days, in OUTsurance’s wording2Report to the police, the insurer and the tracking company at once
9. Unroadworthy or modified carBoth excluded in OUTsurance’s comprehensive wording2Keep the car roadworthy and declare performance modifications
10. Disputes over the amount“Disputed quantum” is among the other recurring complaints1Know whether your schedule pays retail, market or agreed value

What the ombud’s 2025 figures show about rejected car insurance claims

The NFO hears complaints against insurers once an insurer’s own process has run out. Its 2025 annual report is the best published picture of why motor claims end in a dispute:

  • Motor is the biggest line. “Complaints related to motor vehicle insurance accounted for 35,4% of all the complaints finalised/resolved during the year”, ahead of homeowners at 27.5%.
  • Most motor disputes are about accidents: 70%, then theft and hijack claims at 8% and mechanical breakdown claims at 4%.
  • Exclusions lead the rejections. Driving under the influence led, up 67% on 2024. It took over from a lack of due care, which led in 2024, and misrepresentation and non-disclosure at the start of the policy was the other prevalent exclusion.
  • The rest: “disputed quantum and claim delays, the latter increasing by 13%”, plus complaints about repairs and about premiums not paid.
  • The outcome: the non-life division resolved 11,428 complaints, changed the result in 11% of them (its “resolved ratio”), and returned R82.9 million to consumers, in an average of 105 working days.1

Read the other way, the insurer’s decision stood in most complaints. That is why the time to protect a claim is before it happens: almost every reason below is a condition you can read in your policy wording today.

We found no published figure for how many claims each insurer rejects. The nearest measure is the ombud’s count of complaints per insurer and how often it changed the outcome, set out for the 25 largest insurers in our comparison of car insurance companies.

Drunk driving: the most common reason a car insurance claim is rejected

The wordings we read exclude it, and some spell out more than the legal limit. OUTsurance’s comprehensive wording excludes a driver “exceeding the legal limit or fails a breathalyser test”, and one who “refuses to give either a breath or blood sample”.2 Budget’s terms exclude a driver who “drives while under the influence”.3 Refusing a test does not protect a claim under a wording like OUTsurance’s; it is a ground for rejection in its own right.

What a rejection for alcohol means for you, and for the other driver’s damage, is set out in our scenario a crash after a few drinks: what insurance will and won’t cover.

Lack of due care, recklessness and gross negligence

Policies expect you to take reasonable steps to prevent a loss and to limit it once it happens. In 2024 the failure to do so, “also known as a lack of due care, or recklessness”, was the leading reason the ombud saw for a rejected motor claim.1 Wordings also set rules for what you do after a loss: OUTsurance excludes “Unlawfully leaving the scene of an accident”, and Budget gives no cover when someone uses the car without your knowledge and consent unless you lay a criminal charge with the police within 48 hours.2,3

The ombud doesn’t treat every slip as reckless. When a car owner who found her car gone at about 06:00 only phoned the tracking company at about 10:35, the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance (OSTI) found that the insurer “had not proved that the insured was grossly negligent or acted recklessly. At best, the insured was negligent”, and found for her.6

Missing keys can stall a theft claim too; see a missing car key after a theft: why the claim stalls.

Non-disclosure and misrepresentation: what you told your car insurer

Your premium is priced on what you said when you took out the policy, so a wrong answer can undo the claim later. MiWay’s wording, for example, says “Incidents which occurred in the last 3 years need to be disclosed”, “irrespective of whether a claim was submitted or not”.5 Momentum lists “misrepresentation during the application process” among the common reasons it declines claims, with “unapproved driver usage”, “unroadworthy vehicle conditions”, driving under the influence, missing tracking devices “(where specified)” and unpaid premiums.7

A wrong answer on a proposal form can also count against you in court. In Ngako v Bryte (2025) the proposal asked “Is your vehicle fitted with a tracker” and the answer given was “yes”, but no tracker certificate was attached and no agreement with a tracking company was ever concluded; the High Court dismissed the application.8

The details that most often go wrong each have their own page:

Upload your policy schedule for a free written review: we check disclosure, cover type, excess and any tracker requirement.

Get your policy checked

Who was driving: licences and the regular driver

OUTsurance’s and Budget’s wordings exclude a driver without a valid licence, and Budget’s also one who “has an endorsed licence”; King Price gives no cover where the driver has “a licence that’s endorsed”.2,3,4 Foreign licences have time limits that differ by insurer: King Price expects a permanent resident to get “an SA licence within 1 year of becoming a permanent resident”, OUTsurance within five years.2,4

The regular driver matters as much. OUTsurance defines that person as “the person who drives the vehicle most often in any monthly period”.2 Auto & General says occasional use by another licensed driver is covered in most instances, “provided this does not conflict with the noted regular driver”, and that an additional excess may apply.9 So a schedule that names a parent as the regular driver of a car a son or daughter drives most days doesn’t match the definition, and that is the kind of detail a claims assessor checks.

Business, delivery and e-hailing use

Personal policies are priced for private use. MiWay’s wording excludes “carrying fare-paying passengers (like taxi or shuttle services), delivery services”, and every other personal wording we read excludes paid passengers too.5 Business use itself has to be on the policy: King Price says “Only you, your spouse and the regular driver can be insured for business use of your car.”4

If you drive for Uber or Bolt, a personal policy is the wrong cover; see car insurance for Uber and Bolt drivers, and business use not declared for what happens to a claim when it wasn’t.

Tracker not fitted, not the right one, or not working

Where your schedule requires a tracker, the wording usually makes theft and hijack cover depend on it. King Price: “You won’t have theft and hi-jack cover if the required tracking device isn’t installed or isn’t in proper working condition.”4 MiWay says that if the tracker subscription is unpaid, “I will not have a valid claim should my vehicle be stolen or hijacked”, and Naked pays a theft claim only if the device worked, the contract was active and the theft was reported to the tracking company immediately.5,10

The type of tracker matters as much as having one. Old Mutual Insure told brokers in July 2026 that approved early warning tracking devices “remain mandatory for identified high risk vehicles”. On its Motorsure and Justwheels products, any Toyota Hilux, Toyota Fortuner, Isuzu or Mazda Drifter needs a tracker, and “If no tracker is installed there is No theft cover.” On its Elite product a car worth R500,000 to R1,499,999 with no tracker carries an additional excess of 10% of the claim, minimum R15,000.11 Ami lists models, the Isuzu KB and D-Max and every Volkswagen Polo among them, that need “an early warning or similar tracking system by an approved tracking company irrespective of their value”.12 So check that the device in your car is the type your schedule names, not just that a tracker is fitted.

The courts hold owners to it. In Ngako v Bryte a Toyota Quantum (HiAce) claim for R577,800 was rejected because “no tracking device was installed”; the owner never supplied proof of installation, payment or a contract, and the application was dismissed with costs.8 Where the requirement was never properly explained, though, the FAIS Ombud has made the broker pay (see the cases below). Which device your car needs, and how to keep it working, is in our vehicle tracking guide, and the claim itself in stolen while the tracker was offline.

Unpaid premiums and lapsed car insurance policies

A missed debit order doesn’t end cover at once. OUTsurance, Budget, Auto & General and MiWay give 15 days to pay from the second month, and King Price “at least 15 days”.2,3,4,5,13 Miss it for longer and the policy lapses: after two consecutive months at OUTsurance and King Price, after three at Budget, Auto & General and MiWay.2,3,4,5,13 A loss after the policy has lapsed is not covered.

The ombud counts these among its steady complaints.1 See missed a premium, then had a claim.

Reporting a claim too late

Wordings set deadlines. OUTsurance wants an incident reported to it “as soon as possible, but not later than 30 days”, and theft, hijack, fire and deliberate damage reported to the police “within 24 hours of the incident”.2 Pineapple asks for notice “no later than 30 days after the event” and SAPS “within 24 hours” of a loss or theft.14

Lateness costs the claim where it may have cost the recovery. A logistics company reported a stolen trailer to its insurer 12 days after it found it gone; the trailer had two trackers and the tracking company and police were told at once, but the OSTI backed the rejection because the insurer’s investigator “could have possibility resulted in the recovery of the trailer had it been timeously reported”.15

Unroadworthy and modified cars

OUTsurance’s comprehensive wording lists an “Unroadworthy vehicle” and “Modifications to enhance engine performance” among its exclusions.2 So keep tyres, brakes and lights in order, and if you have changed the engine’s performance, tell your insurer before you need to claim, not after.

When the claim is paid, but not in full

Not every complaint is about a rejection. “Disputed quantum”, an argument over how much is paid, is one of the recurring motor complaints, with delays and dissatisfaction with repairs.1 A write-off is settled on the value your schedule names, and if the car is financed the payout can be less than you owe; our page on a car written off: the payout and the finance explains how.

Real car insurance claim cases: what the ombuds and the courts decided

Each case below was read in the ombud’s or the court’s published decision, or in the trade press that reported it. The pattern is consistent: a clear condition the owner didn’t meet is upheld against the owner, and a condition that was never properly explained is often paid by the broker.

Rejected car insurance claims and what happened next
CaseWhy the claim was rejectedOutcome
Toyota Hilux, FAIS Ombud (2026)16A tracker was fitted, but it “did not meet the specifications and functionality required by the insurer”The broker hadn’t specified the device; settled for R820,000
Toyota Prado, FAIS Ombud17A tracker requirement added in April 2023 was never met; the car was stolen in November 2023No proof she was told; the broker was ordered to pay R786,300 plus interest
Toyota Land Cruiser, FAIS Ombud (2025)18The schedule required a tracker within seven days and a backup unitThe broker admitted an administrative error; settled for R812,000
Toyota Fortuner, FAIS Ombud19Stolen with no tracker fittedSending only the policy wording wasn’t enough; settled for R644,000
Land Cruiser, OSTI then FAIS Ombud (2023)20No satellite early-warning device; R312,400 claimThe OSTI dismissed the complaint against the insurer; the FAIS Ombud upheld it against the brokers
Factory immobiliser or tracker, OSTI (2023)21The schedule’s wording on whether a tracker was required was unclearHighlighting words in red was “not effective”; the insurer settled
Tracking company called four hours late, OSTI6The owner phoned the tracking company at about 10:35 after finding the car gone at 06:00Negligent at most, not grossly negligent: found for the owner
Trailer reported 12 days late, OSTI15The insurer was told 12 days after the theftRejection upheld
Toyota Quantum, High Court (2025)8No tracking device installedApplication dismissed with costs

Ombud and court outcomes depend on each case’s facts and wording; they show how the rules are applied, not what will happen to your claim.

Not every case ends in a rejection: in another FAIS matter the insurer paid for a stolen bakkie but deducted an extra theft excess for the missing tracker; emailing the client a standard template had not been adequate, and the broker settled R256,800.22

Upload your policy schedule for a free written review: we check disclosure, cover type, excess and any tracker requirement.

Get your policy checked

If your car insurance claim is rejected: your rights and the deadlines

The Policyholder Protection Rules set out what an insurer owes you once it decides. It must accept, reject or dispute a claim “within a reasonable period”, and tell you in writing within 10 days of deciding, giving “the reasons for the decision, in sufficient detail to enable the claimant to dispute such reasons”.23

The rejection timeline under rule 17.6 of the Policyholder Protection Rules
StepDeadline
Insurer tells you its decision, with reasonsWithin 10 days of deciding
You make representations to the insurerAt least 90 days from receiving the letter
Insurer answers your representationsWithin 45 days of receiving them
Time to take legal actionAt least 6 months after the 90 days end (policies from 1 January 2011)

Rule 17.6.23

Policies repeat these periods: Old Mutual’s terms give 90 days after the rejection letter to object.24

Complaining to the ombud

Start with the insurer: the NFO says “you must first contact your insurer to try to resolve the problem”. After that, “Our service is free to complainants.”25 It sets no limit on the amount claimed, and lodging a complaint suspends any time bar and prescription until the complaint is finalised.26 The NFO took over from the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance on 1 March 2024; it is on 0860 800 900 and info@nfosa.co.za.27,28

A complaint about the advice you were given, such as a broker who never told you about a tracker requirement, goes to the FAIS Ombud instead.29 Our guides take you through disputing a declined claim step by step and which ombud handles which complaint.

How to protect your car insurance claim before anything happens

  1. Read the schedule, not just the quote: it lists the regular driver, the overnight address, the use, the value and any security requirement.
  2. Correct anything that has changed: a new driver, a new address, a modification, or a car now used for work.
  3. If a tracker is required, fit the device the schedule names on time, keep its subscription paid and keep the fitment certificate.
  4. Keep your licence valid and never drive after drinking.
  5. After a loss, report it to the police within 24 hours, to the tracking company at once, and to the insurer as soon as you can.
  6. If you are rejected, ask for the reasons in writing and use the 90 days to respond before you go to the ombud.
  7. When you next compare car insurance, compare these conditions as well as the premium, and know what the cheapest car insurance covers before you choose it.

Questions people ask about rejected claims

Usually on an exclusion in the policy. In 2025 the leading one at the ombud was driving under the influence of alcohol, which overtook a lack of due care; misrepresentation or non-disclosure when the policy was taken out was the other common one. Unlicensed drivers, undeclared business use, a missing or broken tracker, unpaid premiums and late reporting are the other common reasons.

We found no published claim rejection rate per insurer in South Africa. The closest public measure is the ombud’s yearly count of complaints per insurer and the share it decided in the policyholder’s favour, which counts complaints across all non-life cover, not rejected car claims.

Under some wordings, yes. OUTsurance’s comprehensive wording excludes a driver who refuses to give either a breath or blood sample, as well as one over the legal limit or who fails a breathalyser test. Check the exclusions in your own wording.

Under the Policyholder Protection Rules an insurer must decide within a reasonable period and tell you in writing within 10 days of deciding, with reasons detailed enough for you to dispute them.

You have at least 90 days from receiving the rejection letter to make representations to the insurer, which must answer within 45 days. For policies from 1 January 2011, the time to take legal action runs for at least six months after those 90 days.

No. The National Financial Ombud Scheme says its service is free to complainants and sets no limit on the amount claimed. You must first give your insurer the chance to resolve the complaint.

If your schedule requires a tracker, yes. King Price’s wording, for example, gives no theft and hijack cover if the required device isn’t installed or isn’t in proper working condition, and MiWay’s says an unpaid tracker subscription means no valid theft claim.

Often, yes. MiWay’s wording says incidents in the last three years must be disclosed whether or not a claim was submitted. Misrepresentation and non-disclosure at the start of a policy is one of the reasons the ombud sees most often.

Usually, if you pay within the grace period. OUTsurance, Budget, Auto & General and MiWay give 15 days from the second month, and King Price at least 15 days. After two or three missed months, depending on the insurer, the policy lapses.

A complaint about the advice you were given goes to the FAIS Ombud. In several tracker cases it has made the broker pay, including R786,300 plus interest for a Toyota Prado.

Sources

  1. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “Annual Report 2025 (non-life division; statistics per top 25 participants)”, 2025 calendar year, published 2026. nfosa.co.za
  2. OUTsurance, “Personal policy document”, version V 05.03.25. outsurance.co.za
  3. Budget Insurance, “Terms and Conditions including Budget Lite”, May 2024. budgetinsurance.co.za
  4. King Price, “Personal insurance policy document”, version 09/26. kingprice.co.za
  5. MiWay, “Policy wording – Mipersonal insurance”, updated March 2026. miway-website.cdn.prismic.io
  6. Moonstone, “Three cases focusing on the insured’s reporting obligations following a vehicle theft”, 1 February 2024. moonstone.co.za
  7. Momentum, “Car insurance”, read 2 November 2026. momentum.co.za
  8. High Court, Gauteng Division, Pretoria (SAFLII), “Ngako v Bryte Insurance Company Ltd and Another [2025] ZAGPPHC 81”, 31 January 2025. saflii.org
  9. Auto & General, “Car insurance”, read 2 November 2026. autogen.co.za
  10. Naked, “Naked policy wording – car”, last updated 31 January 2025. docs.naked.insure
  11. Old Mutual Insure, “Reaffirming our vehicle tracking device and recovery system requirements (broker communication, copy on a broker’s site)”, 16 July 2026. msbia.co.za
  12. Ami Underwriting Managers, “Updated vehicle tracking and security requirements policy”, 16 July 2025. ami.co.za
  13. Auto & General, “Terms & conditions, including Auto & General Express”, December 2023. autogen.co.za
  14. Pineapple, “Car insurance policy wording (summary page)”, page modified 11 September 2026. pineapple.co.za
  15. Masthead, “Ombudsman’s Briefcase: non-compliance with reporting requirements”, 16 February 2024. masthead.co.za
  16. FAIS Ombud, “Vehicle insurance: tracking device (settlement)”, March 2026. faisombud.co.za
  17. FAIS Ombud, “Duty of care: motor vehicle tracking device”, no date shown, read 30 October 2026. faisombud.co.za
  18. FAIS Ombud, “Material disclosure and duty of care: motor vehicle tracking device”, complaint summary, settlement accepted 27 October 2025. faisombud.co.za
  19. FAIS Ombud, “Minimum security requirements for motor vehicle insurance”, no date shown (early 2023), read 30 October 2026. faisombud.co.za
  20. Moonstone, “Insurance brokers ordered to pay R300 000 after failing to disclose crucial policy requirement”, 18 January 2024. moonstone.co.za
  21. Moonstone, “A clear case of an ambiguous policy wording?”, 14 September 2023. moonstone.co.za
  22. The Citizen, “FAIS Ombud annual report: lessons on car insurance”, 2 November 2024. citizen.co.za
  23. FSCA (LawLibrary consolidation), “Policyholder Protection Rules (Short-term Insurance), 2017, as amended 1 October 2018”, GN 1433 of 15 December 2017. lawlibrary.org.za
  24. Old Mutual, “Old Mutual Car Insurance general terms & conditions”, September 2021. django-om.iwyzelife.co.za
  25. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “How to complain”, read 2 November 2026. nfosa.co.za
  26. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “FAQs”, read 2 November 2026. nfosa.co.za
  27. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “About us”, read 2 November 2026. nfosa.co.za
  28. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “Contact us”, read 2 November 2026. nfosa.co.za
  29. OUTsurance, “Complaints resolution policy”, April 2025. outsurance.co.za