OneCompare

Insurer reviews · Budget Insurance

Is Budget Insurance a good insurer? Reviews, ratings and complaints

Yes, by the ratings that exist: Budget Insurance has 4.7 stars from 12,039 Hellopeter reviews in the past year, 4.8 on Google Play and a 4% ombud ratio for 2025. Reviewers score its agents and pricing well above the industry; claims sit just above it, and repairs fall below it.

Checked on 11 November 2026 against Hellopeter, Google Play, the App Store, the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 annual report, the 2025 CE Index reports and Budget’s own pages.

Budget Insurance car insurance: cover, excess and contact

Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email and SMS.

Budget Insurance ratings at a glance

Budget Insurance ratings at a glance (Hellopeter and app stores seen 11 November 2026)
MeasureResult
Hellopeter stars4.7 out of 5, from 12,039 reviews in the last 12 months1
Hellopeter TrustIndex10 out of 101
Reviews on Hellopeter, all time40,0401
Hellopeter NPS391
Average reply time (all / negative reviews)17 min / 43 min1
Negative reviews replied to99%1
Hellopeter rank#10 in Insurance, #8 in Car Insurance1
Google Play4.8 from 9,605 ratings (Budget Insurance App)2
App Store (South Africa)4.7 from 7,805 ratings (Budget Insurance App)3
Ombud resolved ratio (2025 report)4% (Budget Insurance Company Ltd); non-life division 11%4
CE Index 2025 (reported early 2026)Joint 2nd overall; joint top digital score5,6

Hellopeter’s figures change daily; its TrustIndex mixes star ratings with how quickly a business replies. The ombud ratio is complaints decided with some benefit to the client, divided by complaints closed. These ratings are other sites’ figures, not OneCompare’s, and naming Budget Insurance here doesn’t mean it endorses or partners with us.

What Budget Insurance clients praise

Budget’s strongest score in Hellopeter’s table is Agent Quality, 4.3 against the industry’s 4.1. Pricing & Premiums comes next at 3.5, well clear of the industry’s 2.7, with Communication at 3.5 against 3.0 and Claims Handling at 3.0, one notch above 2.9.1

Hellopeter’s summary of the praise is about patience and price. Reviewers mention consultants who explain the policy clearly, premiums lowered when they asked, and glass and roadside claims that were sorted out quickly. On Hellopeter, Budget’s Net Promoter Score is 39.1

Budget Insurance complaints: what reviewers raise

The one Budget topic below the industry is Repair Quality, 2.5 against 2.9. The complaint themes behind it are delays on claims and repairs, stretches with no news, workmanship from third-party repairers, documents asked for more than once, and claims turned down on what the reviewer sees as a technicality.1

Budget replies to its reviewers in 17 minutes on average and to negative reviews in 43 minutes, answering 99% of the negative ones. Its 12,039 reviews in the last 12 months are the fourth-highest count of the fifteen insurers on this page; it has 40,040 in all.1

Before you take a Budget Insurance quote, compare it: fill in one form and we send you quotes from other insurers by email and SMS.

Compare quotes

Budget Insurance at the ombud (NFO 2025)

The National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 figures show Budget Insurance Company Ltd with 276 complaints registered and 250 formal complaints opened. Of the 262 formal complaints it closed, 11 went the client’s way in some part, a resolved ratio of 4% against 11% for the non-life division as a whole.4

“Resolved in favour of the complainant” means the ombud’s process left the client with some benefit: a decision changed, a claim paid or a settlement improved. The counts are not a rate per policy, so compare ratios rather than totals when you set Budget against a bigger or smaller insurer.4

Budget Insurance awards and its own claims

In the 2025 Customer Experience Index for short-term insurance, compiled by the University of Pretoria’s Prof. Adré Schreuder from a survey of 6,384 consumers, Budget shared second place with Virseker and shared the top digital score with Dialdirect.5,6

Budget’s home page, read on 11 November 2026, promises “We’ll BEAT your car insurance premium or PAY you”, with terms and conditions attached, and says it took “1st place for Best Digital Channel at the 2025 Customer Experience Index”. Both are Budget’s own claims; read the offer’s terms before you rely on it.7

Who owns Budget Insurance?

Budget Insurance Company Ltd holds its own insurance licence and is FSP 18178. Its holding company is Telesure Investment Holdings, which its May 2026 PAIA manual describes as the holding company of Budget, Auto & General, Dial Direct and First for Women. Each of those four brands is a separate licensed insurer.8,9

How Budget Insurance compares with 14 other insurers

Fifteen car insurers on Hellopeter and at the ombud (Hellopeter seen 11 November 2026 for the first ten; 16 November 2026 for Santam, Old Mutual Insure, Momentum Insure, Absa Insurance and Virseker)
InsurerHellopeter starsClaims HandlingRepair QualityPricing & PremiumsOmbud resolved ratio 2025
Dial Direct4.73.12.53.4Not in the top 25
Budget Insurance4.73.02.53.54%
Auto & General4.63.32.84.14%
Pineapple4.62.62.33.217% (underwriter, all brands)
1st for Women4.62.72.23.79%
OUTsurance4.84.13.93.83%
iWYZE4.63.22.23.510% (underwriter, all brands)
MiWay4.83.74.23.85%
King Price4.83.83.73.94%
Dotsure4.83.82.53.47%
Santam4.83.32.64.17%
Old Mutual Insure4.83.5–3.910%
Momentum Insure4.63.32.63.811%
Absa Insurance4.51.91.63.413%
Virseker4.63.12.43.44% (underwriter, all brands)
Industry figure–2.92.92.711% (non-life division)

Stars and topic scores from each insurer’s Hellopeter profile and score table, seen 11 November 2026 for the first ten and 16 November 2026 for the last five; the industry figure is Hellopeter’s for insurance. Ombud ratios from the National Financial Ombud Scheme’s 2025 table of its 25 largest non-life participants, where a row is the licence, so an underwriter’s row covers every brand it carries.1,4,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23

More insurer reviews: Dial Direct reviews, Auto & General reviews, Pineapple reviews, 1st for Women reviews, OUTsurance reviews, iWYZE reviews, MiWay reviews, King Price reviews, Dotsure reviews, Santam reviews, Old Mutual Insure reviews, Momentum Insure reviews, Absa Insurance reviews, Virseker reviews.

Before you buy Budget Insurance: what to check

Because repair and claim delays lead the complaints, ask at quote stage how Budget appoints repairers and assessors, and how you will hear about progress. When you claim, send every document in one go, keep copies and note the date, so a second request can be answered the same day.

If a claim is turned down, ask for the exact policy clause in writing. You can take it to Budget’s dispute team and then, free of charge, to the National Financial Ombud Scheme. Before you accept the premium, compare it with other insurers on the same cover and the same excess.

Compare your Budget Insurance premium

Already with Budget Insurance or have a Budget Insurance quote? Send it to us on WhatsApp and we’ll get you comparison quotes from other insurers.

Get quotes compared on WhatsApp →
OneCompare (Pty) Ltd is an authorised financial services provider (FSP 55551). We are not Budget Insurance Company Ltd and don’t act for it. By messaging us you agree that we may use your details to get you quotes, in line with POPIA and our privacy policy.
Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email and SMS.

Compare car insurance quotes from every insurer →

Questions about Budget Insurance reviews

On 11 November 2026 Budget had 4.7 stars and a TrustIndex of 10 on Hellopeter, from 12,039 reviews in the last 12 months, and ranked eighth in Hellopeter’s Car Insurance category.

Hellopeter scores Budget’s claims handling at 3.0 against an industry 2.9. Reviewers praise quick glass and roadside claims, and complain about delays, repeated document requests and repair workmanship.

In 2025 the ombud opened 250 formal complaints about Budget and closed 262, 11 of them with some benefit to the client: a 4% resolved ratio.

It is rated 4.8 on Google Play from 9,605 ratings and 4.7 on the South African App Store from 7,805, both seen on 11 November 2026.

Budget advertises “We’ll BEAT your car insurance premium or PAY you” with terms and conditions. That is Budget’s own offer; read its terms for what counts as a like-for-like quote.

Telesure Investment Holdings, which also holds Auto & General, Dial Direct and First for Women.

Sources

  1. Hellopeter, “Budget Insurance reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  2. Google Play, “Budget Insurance App (app listing)”, seen 11 November 2026. play.google.com
  3. Apple App Store (South Africa), “Budget Insurance App (app listing)”, seen 11 November 2026. apps.apple.com
  4. National Financial Ombud Scheme, “Annual Report 2025 (non-life division; statistics per top 25 participants)”, 2025 calendar year, published 2026. nfosa.co.za
  5. InsuranceBiz, “Short-term insurance delivers mixed customer experience results, index shows (CE Index 2025)”, 28 January 2026. insurancebiz.co.za
  6. Moonstone, “Short-term insurers strengthen customer experience, but execution gaps persist (CE Index 2025)”, 5 February 2026. moonstone.co.za
  7. Budget Insurance, “Home page (awards and offer)”, read 11 November 2026. budgetinsurance.co.za
  8. FSCA, “Authorised Financial Service Providers search”, read 2 November 2026. fsca.co.za
  9. Telesure Investment Holdings, “PAIA manual”, May 2026. tihsa.co.za
  10. Hellopeter, “Dialdirect reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  11. Hellopeter, “Auto & General reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  12. Hellopeter, “Pineapple reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  13. Hellopeter, “1st for Women reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  14. Hellopeter, “OUTsurance reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  15. Hellopeter, “iWYZE reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  16. Hellopeter, “MiWay reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  17. Hellopeter, “King Price reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  18. Hellopeter, “dotsure.co.za reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 11 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  19. Hellopeter, “Santam reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  20. Hellopeter, “Old Mutual Insure reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  21. Hellopeter, “Momentum Insure reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  22. Hellopeter, “Absa Insurance Company Limited reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com
  23. Hellopeter, “Virseker reviews (profile, score table and AI summary)”, seen 16 November 2026. hellopeter.com

Ratings move every day. Check Budget Insurance’s Hellopeter profile and the app stores for today’s figures, and confirm cover and prices with the insurer before you buy.