OneCompare

Comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive car insurance in South Africa: what it covers, what it costs and what it leaves out

Comprehensive insurance pays for your own car in an accident, and if it is stolen, hijacked, burnt or damaged by weather, as well as for the damage you cause to other people’s cars and property.1,2 It is the cover a bank usually asks for on a financed car, under the finance agreement rather than the law.3,4 The lowest prices insurers publish start at R300 a month at Naked and R349 for Discovery’s Core Plan.5,6

Start your car insurance quote

Updated 12 November 2026 · Reviewed by the OneCompare Editorial team, 12 November 2026

Checked on 12 November 2026 against OUTsurance’s, Budget’s, MiWay’s, Naked’s, Discovery’s, Santam’s and Momentum’s own pages and policy wordings, and Old Mutual Insure’s and Bryte’s tracker rules. General information, not advice: your policy wording and schedule decide your cover.

Comprehensive vs third party, fire and theft vs third party only
What it pays forComprehensiveThird party, fire and theftThird party only
Damage you cause to other people’s cars and property✓ Yes✓ Yes✓ Yes
Your car stolen or hijacked✓ Yes✓ Yes✗ No
Fire damage to your car✓ Yes✓ Yes✗ No
Accident damage to your own car✓ Yes✗ No✗ No

From OUTsurance’s policy wording, Budget’s comprehensive and car insurance pages and Naked’s car insurance page; the edges differ by insurer, so check your schedule.1,2,5,7

What does comprehensive insurance mean?

In South Africa, comprehensive insurance means the car cover that pays for accident damage to your own car, for theft, hijacking, fire and weather damage, and for the damage you cause to other people: OUTsurance’s wording says “You are covered for accidental damage to your own vehicle as well as damage to other people’s property. Your vehicle is also covered for theft and hijack.”1

So in South Africa comprehensive cover includes accident damage. Budget lists what its comprehensive cover pays for as “theft, hijacking, fire, natural disasters, accidental damage, and third-party liability”, and Naked says comprehensive “covers your own car as well as damage you cause to others”.2,3

What does comprehensive insurance cover?

Comprehensive insurance covers your own car against accidents, theft, hijacking, fire and weather damage such as hail and flood, and pays for the damage you cause to other people’s cars and property up to your limit; each insurer’s page lists the same core events, with its own extras and limits on top.2,8,9

  • OUTsurance: cover “against loss or damage caused by theft, hijacking, accidents, flood, hail and even intentional damage caused by someone else”, and up to R5 million for damage to a third party.8
  • Budget: “theft, hijacking, fire, natural disasters, accidental damage, and third-party liability”.2
  • MiWay: accident and intentional damage, theft and hijack, fire and explosion, earthquake, storm, hail, flood and snow, window and glass cover, locks and keys, towing, and up to R5,000,000 liability to other parties.9
  • Naked: comprehensive “protects your car when things go wrong from dings and dents to total write-offs”.3

What are the benefits of having comprehensive insurance?

The main benefit is that your own car is covered, not only the other driver’s: an accident you cause, a theft, a hijacking or a hailstorm is paid by the insurer, less your excess, instead of by you.1,2 Insurers add extras on top, such as OUTsurance’s 12-month guarantee on repairs and the cash back schemes below.8

Need comprehensive cover? Compare quotes on the same excess and extras.

Compare quotes

What is not covered by comprehensive insurance?

Comprehensive insurance does not pay when you break the policy’s conditions: OUTsurance says claims won’t be accepted if the driver was under the influence, the car wasn’t roadworthy or the driver didn’t have a valid licence, and Momentum lists unapproved drivers, a missing required tracker, unpaid premiums and misrepresentation as common reasons claims are declined.4,10

  • The excess: every claim pays less your excess, which you choose with OUTsurance and is a R5,000 flexible amount on MiWay’s comprehensive cover.8,9
  • Extras you didn’t choose: car hire is an optional extra at OUTsurance, for up to 30 days after a claimable accident, theft or hijacking.8
  • Theft without a required tracker: see the tracker rules below.

Comprehensive insurance claims

A comprehensive claim pays for your own car as well as the other side’s, but always less your excess and only for the extras on your schedule, so check both before you claim.8 Every insurer’s claims line is on our page on car insurance companies in South Africa, and our guide to why car insurance claims get declined covers each reason with the ombud’s figures.

What is full comprehensive insurance?

Full comprehensive insurance is comprehensive cover with every risk on the policy selected; MiWay’s wording says that where you have selected all the risks, “I will enjoy full comprehensive cover.” “Full cover” and “fully comprehensive” are everyday names for the same thing.11

Is comprehensive insurance full coverage?

It is the fullest level of car cover, but not cover for everything: even with every risk selected, a claim is paid less the excess, optional extras such as car hire pay only if you added them, and breaking a condition, such as driving without a valid licence, can still void a claim.4,8

Is comprehensive insurance required by law?

No. It is not legally required on any car, financed or not: OUTsurance says car insurance “is generally not legally compulsory, but if your vehicle is financed, your finance provider may require specific cover (often comprehensive) as a condition of the loan”, and Naked says “if your car is financed, your bank will usually require comprehensive cover.” It is the finance agreement, not the law, that asks for it.3,4

Which is better, 3rd party or comprehensive?

Comprehensive is better if you couldn’t pay to repair or replace your own car, and it is what a bank usually asks for on a financed car; third party only is cheaper but pays nothing for your own car, so it suits a car you could replace yourself.3,5 The two are set side by side in our guide to comprehensive vs third party car insurance, and third party cover has its own page: third party insurance.

Comprehensive cover from each insurer: what its own page says

What each insurer’s own page says its comprehensive cover includes (read 12 November 2026)
InsurerLiability to othersRepairs and car hireCash back or reward
OUTsuranceUp to R5 million (extendable)8Repairs guaranteed for 12 months; car hire for up to 30 days, optional8OUTbonus: 10% of car premiums back after three claim-free years4
MiWayUp to R5,000,0009WeDrive take-me-home service six times a year; towing and storage9Micashback: 10% of premiums back every two claim-free years12
BudgetThird-party liability included2Not stated on its comprehensive pageOptional Cash Back Bonus: 15% after two claim-free years, then 10%13
SantamNot stated on its pages we readNot stated on its pages we readCashBack: 10% after three claim-free years; SmartPark up to 20% off under 15,000 km a year14,15
NakedNot stated on its car pageNot stated on its car pageCoverPause: switch off accident cover while parked, “save up to 50%”5

Each entry is the insurer’s own published information. Your schedule sets your own limits, extras and rewards.

How much does comprehensive insurance cover cost?

Comprehensive insurance cover costs from R300 a month at Naked and R349 for Discovery’s Core Plan, the lowest prices on insurers’ own pages on 12 November 2026, but those are starting prices for the lowest-risk driver and car; your own premium depends on your age, address, claims history, car, excess and security.5,6,10

  • Discovery: Core Plan from R349, Essential from R400, Classic from R500 and Purple from R600 a month.6,16
  • Pineapple: its comprehensive examples start with a Suzuki Swift at R531.02 a month.17
  • OUTsurance: “as little as R578pm*”, what one client pays.4
  • Dialdirect: comprehensive cover “starting from R27 per day (R798 pm)”.18

Each insurer’s lowest advertised price, and the same car priced at 13 insurers, are on our page on the cheapest comprehensive car insurance.

Need comprehensive cover? Compare quotes on the same excess and extras.

Compare quotes

Excess on comprehensive cover

Every comprehensive claim pays less your excess. OUTsurance’s comprehensive cover has a fixed excess you choose, and MiWay’s a R5,000 flexible excess.8,9 Some insurers add an excess for a missing tracker: on Old Mutual Insure’s Allsure policies, a car worth R500,000 to R1,499,999 with no tracker carries an additional excess of 5%, minimum R2,750, and on its Elite policies 10% of the claim, minimum R15,000.19 How to weigh a higher excess against a lower premium is in our excess guide.

Comprehensive cover on a financed car

Your bank or finance house usually asks for comprehensive cover until the car is paid off, as a condition of the finance agreement.3,4 If the car is written off early in the loan, you can owe more than the insurer pays: Naked’s shortfall cover pays the difference “if your financed car is written off and you owe more than its retail value”, and OUTsurance offers credit shortfall cover as an extra.3,8

More on insuring a financed car and credit shortfall cover.

Can I cancel comprehensive once my car is paid off?

You can change it: the finance condition ends when the car is paid off, and the cover level is then your choice. Before you drop to third party, ask whether you could replace the car yourself.3

Retail, market or trade value

The value your policy pays on a write-off is on your schedule, so check it before you claim. OUTsurance’s comprehensive cover pays theft “up to the retail value, less the excess”, and its cheaper Essential cover pays accident damage up to 40% of the retail value.8 Naked’s shortfall cover works from the car’s retail value.3 When you compare quotes, check they settle on the same basis, or the cheaper one may pay less on a write-off.

Tracker rules on comprehensive cover

Old Mutual Insure asks for a tracking device on cars worth R500,000 to R1,499,999 on its Allsure policies, and for an early-warning tracker from R1,500,000, without which there is no theft cover. Its high theft risk list includes the Toyota Hilux, Fortuner, Land Cruiser and Prado (from 2017), the Ford Ranger (from 2007), the Isuzu D-MAX, the Nissan NP200 and the VW Polo.19 Bryte requires a tracking device on all other vehicles worth R750,000 or more.20 Every insurer’s rule is in our guide to when an insurer requires a tracker.

How insurers lower a comprehensive premium

  • Drive less: Santam’s SmartPark takes up to 20% off if you drive less than 15,000 km a year, and Naked’s CoverPause “save[s] up to 50%” on days the car is parked.5,15
  • Insure more than one car: King Price gives up to 10% off both cars when two are comprehensively insured, 15% for three and 20% for four or more; MiWay gives up to 25% off the lowest premium when you insure two cars.9,21
  • Stay claim-free: OUTsurance and Santam pay 10% of premiums back after three claim-free years, Budget’s optional Cash Back Bonus 15% after two, and MiWay 10% every two years.4,12,13,14

Reporting a claim on time

OUTsurance’s wording asks you to report a theft or hijacking to the police within 24 hours, and to report any claim to OUTsurance “as soon as possible, but not later than 30 days, after any incident”.1 Other insurers set their own times, so check your wording.

Comprehensive insurance: questions people ask

In South Africa, comprehensive insurance means car cover that pays for accident damage to your own car, for theft, hijacking, fire and weather damage, and for damage you cause to others: OUTsurance’s wording says you are covered for accidental damage to your own vehicle and damage to other people’s property.

Comprehensive insurance covers your own car against accidents, theft, hijacking, fire and weather damage such as hail and flood, and pays for the damage you cause to other people’s cars and property up to your limit; Budget lists theft, hijacking, fire, natural disasters, accidental damage and third-party liability.

Comprehensive insurance does not pay when you break the policy’s conditions: OUTsurance says claims won’t be accepted if the driver was under the influence, the car wasn’t roadworthy or the driver had no valid licence, and Momentum also lists unapproved drivers, a missing required tracker, unpaid premiums and misrepresentation. Every claim also pays less your excess.

Full comprehensive insurance is comprehensive cover with every risk on the policy selected, which MiWay’s wording calls “full comprehensive cover”, and it is not legally required on a financed car: the bank’s finance agreement usually asks for it, as OUTsurance and Naked both say, and the law does not. Full cover and fully comprehensive are everyday names for the same thing.

Comprehensive is better if you couldn’t pay to repair or replace your own car, and it is what a bank usually asks for on a financed car; third party only is cheaper but pays nothing for your own car, so it suits a car you could replace yourself. Comprehensive vs third party →

Comprehensive insurance cover costs from R300 a month at Naked and R349 for Discovery’s Core Plan, the lowest prices on insurers’ own pages on 12 November 2026, but those are starting prices for the lowest-risk driver and car; your premium depends on your age, address, claims, car, excess and security.

You need fully comprehensive car insurance if your car is financed, because the bank usually requires it under the finance agreement, or if you couldn’t pay to repair or replace your car; the law doesn’t require it, so on a paid-off car, third party cover is an option. Compare both on the same car before you decide.

Not unless your policy wording says so: a comprehensive policy insures the car on your schedule, and the insurers’ pages we read describe who may drive your car, not cover for you in someone else’s; Momentum says someone else may drive your car with your permission and a valid licence. Your policy wording decides. Car insurance terms explained →

The main benefit of comprehensive insurance is that your own car is covered as well as other people’s property, so an accident you cause, a theft, a hijacking or a hailstorm is paid by the insurer, less your excess, and insurers add extras such as repair guarantees and cash back.

No type of car insurance is best for everyone, because each suits a different car: comprehensive suits a financed car or one you couldn’t afford to replace, and third party only or third party, fire and theft suit an older, paid-off car you could replace yourself. Compare quotes on the cover you need. Compare car insurance quotes →

Third party only is the cheapest kind of car insurance, from R70 a month at Naked, and its comprehensive cover starts at R300 a month (both read 12 November 2026), but no insurer is cheapest for every driver, because each prices your own car, address, record and excess. Every insurer’s lowest advertised price is on our cheapest car insurance page. Cheapest car insurance in South Africa →

Yes, full cover is the same as comprehensive: full cover, fully comprehensive and full comprehensive are everyday names for comprehensive car insurance, which pays for your own car in an accident, theft or hijacking as well as for other people’s property. Even full cover pays less the excess and covers only the extras on your schedule.

No, comprehensive cover is not required by law in South Africa: car insurance is not legally compulsory, but if your car is financed, the finance agreement with the bank usually requires comprehensive cover until the car is paid off, as OUTsurance and Naked both say on their own pages. On a paid-off car, the cover level is your choice.

Yes, you can change or cancel comprehensive cover once your car is paid off, because the bank’s condition in the finance agreement ends when the finance is settled and the cover level is then your choice, though check first that you could repair or replace the car yourself. Third party only pays nothing for your own car.

Yes, on the comprehensive policies we read: OUTsurance names hail, MiWay lists storm, hail and flood, and Budget names natural disasters. The excess applies.

Not always. If you owe more than the car’s value, the gap is yours unless you have shortfall cover: Naked’s pays the difference if a financed car is written off and you owe more than its retail value.

Sources

  1. OUTsurance, “Personal policy wording (reporting a claim, car hire)”, version V 05.03.25, read 12 November 2026. outsurance.co.za
  2. Budget Insurance, “Comprehensive car insurance”, read 12 November 2026. budgetinsurance.co.za
  3. Naked, “Car insurance: “Is car insurance compulsory in South Africa?” and other questions”, read 12 November 2026. naked.insure
  4. OUTsurance, “Car insurance”, read 12 November 2026. outsurance.co.za
  5. Naked, “Car insurance (prices)”, read 12 November 2026. naked.insure
  6. Discovery, “Core Plan: affordable car insurance from R349”, read 12 November 2026. discovery.co.za
  7. Budget Insurance, “Car insurance”, read 12 November 2026. budgetinsurance.co.za
  8. OUTsurance, “Comprehensive car insurance”, read 12 November 2026. outsurance.co.za
  9. MiWay, “Car insurance (cover table and multi-car savings)”, read 12 November 2026. miway.co.za
  10. Momentum Insure, “Car insurance (Safety Returns cash back; noted drivers)”, read 12 November 2026. momentum.co.za
  11. MiWay, “Policy wording – Mipersonal insurance”, updated March 2026. miway-website.cdn.prismic.io
  12. MiWay, “Micashback”, read 12 November 2026. miway.co.za
  13. Budget Insurance, “Cash Back Bonus”, read 12 November 2026. budgetinsurance.co.za
  14. Santam, “CashBack”, read 12 November 2026. santam.co.za
  15. Santam, “SmartPark: save up to 20% for driving less”, read 12 November 2026. santam.co.za
  16. Discovery, “Car insurance (plan prices: Core, Essential, Classic and Purple)”, read 12 November 2026. discovery.co.za
  17. Pineapple, “Car insurance (premium examples)”, read 12 November 2026. pineapple.co.za
  18. Dialdirect, “Car insurance (page description)”, read 12 November 2026. dialdirect.co.za
  19. Old Mutual Insure, “Reaffirming our vehicle tracking device and recovery system requirements (16 July 2026, copy on a broker’s site)”, 16 July 2026, read 12 November 2026. msbia.co.za
  20. Bryte Insurance, “Product wording and excess changes, effective 1 April 2023 (copy on a broker’s site)”, February 2023, read 12 November 2026. swissfin.co.za
  21. King Price, “Maximise your car insurance savings with King Price’s multiple car discount (blog)”, 16 January 2025, read 12 November 2026. blog.kingprice.co.za

Insurers’ wordings, prices and rules are each insurer’s own published information unless a source says otherwise. They change, so confirm the details in your quote and on your policy schedule. Naming an insurer here does not mean it endorses OneCompare.