Car marketplaces · AutoTrader reviews
AutoTrader reviews: is AutoTrader legit?
AutoTrader is rated 4.3 out of 5 from 40 Hellopeter reviews in the last 12 months, with a TrustIndex of 7.2.1 Its app is rated 4.8 from 9 182 ratings on the App Store2 and 4.7 from 23 931 reviews on Google Play.3 Yes, AutoTrader is legit: it has been part of Naspers-owned OLX Group since 2017.4 The risk on any marketplace is the seller, not the site: AutoTrader’s own advice is to check the market value, ask for a landline and report a scam at once.5
This is OneCompare’s summary of AutoTrader’s (Auto Trader, also typed autotrader sa or autotradersa) ratings on every platform, how its dealer reviews work, the scams its safety page warns about and how to complain. AutoTrader is an online marketplace: the cars are sold by the dealers and private sellers who list them. Scores as at 17 November 2026.
Updated 17 November 2026 · Reviewed by the OneCompare Editorial team, 17 November 2026
AutoTrader South Africa: contact number and cars for sale by city
AutoTrader ratings on every platform
| Platform | Rating | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| Hellopeter | 4.3 out of 5; TrustIndex 7.2 out of 10; 35th in Car Dealerships1 | 40 reviews in the last 12 months (217 all time); NPS 36; 88% of negative reviews replied to |
| Google (Randburg office) | 4.0 out of 56 | 82 reviews |
| App Store | 4.8 out of 52 | 9 182 ratings |
| Google Play | 4.7 out of 53 | 23 931 reviews; 1 million+ downloads |
These are each platform’s figures, not OneCompare’s, and they change daily. The app scores rate the app; Hellopeter and Google rate AutoTrader as a business. Businesses with similar names, such as Auto Traders, Prestige Autotraders and Cape Auto Traders, are other companies with their own profiles.
AutoTrader dealer reviews: how they work
Reviews of the dealers on AutoTrader are a separate thing from reviews of AutoTrader. After you contact a dealership through AutoTrader, AutoTrader sends you an SMS or email within a day inviting you to review it. You give one to five stars and write a review, and the dealer can reply.7
A dealer’s score combines its star rating, how many reviews it has and how recent they are. “No Recent Reviews” means the dealer hasn’t had recent feedback yet, not that it is new or bad. Questions about a review go to customerservice@autotrader.co.za.7 Read a dealer’s recent reviews, and its replies, before you travel to see a car.
Is AutoTrader legit?
AutoTrader has been running in South Africa since 1992, says it gets over 11 million visits a month, and is a Premium Associated member of naamsa.8 It is part of Naspers-owned OLX Group,4 which lists AutoTrader as one of its brands, with offices in Johannesburg and Cape Town.9 It publishes a head office address, an email address and an enquiry form.10
A legitimate marketplace doesn’t make every seller on it legitimate. AutoTrader lists cars for thousands of dealers and private sellers, and the checks below are what protect you.
AutoTrader scams: WhatsApp, deposit and payment scams
People search for AutoTrader WhatsApp, deposit, payment and email scams. Whatever the channel, AutoTrader’s safety page names the same warning signs: a price far below the market value, because prices that look too good to be true are where most frauds start, and a seller who can’t be reached on a landline.5 Don’t pay a deposit for a car you haven’t seen, whatever the reason given.
If you’ve been scammed
Buying safely on AutoTrader
Put AutoTrader’s own advice together with what its listings show you, and a safe purchase looks like this:
- Compare the price with similar cars. Many listings carry AutoTrader’s Fair Price or High Price rating; a car far below the going rate is the warning sign AutoTrader names.5,11
- Know who you’re buying from. Premium listings come from verified premium dealers; a private seller is a private person.12
- Phone the seller, on a landline if you can.5
- See the car, and match its papers to the seller, before any money moves.
- Arrange your insurance before you collect the car.
Warranty and returns on a car from AutoTrader
AutoTrader doesn’t sell the cars, so it gives no warranty and takes no returns: the warranty, if there is one, comes from the dealer who sells you the car, or from a warranty you buy yourself. Ask the dealer in writing what warranty comes with the car, how long it lasts and who handles the claims. A private seller gives no warranty unless you agree one in writing. A dispute with a dealer can go to the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa.5
How to complain about AutoTrader or a dealer on it
| Complaint about | Where to take it |
|---|---|
| AutoTrader itself | customerservice@autotrader.co.za, or the enquiry form on its contact page10 |
| A dealer review | customerservice@autotrader.co.za7 |
| A dealer’s car or sale | The dealer first, then the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa (miosa.co.za)5 |
| A scam | AutoTrader customer service at once, then Crime Line (SMS 32211), 10111 or saps.gov.za5 |
AutoTrader app reviews
The AutoTrader app scores higher than AutoTrader does as a business: 4.8 from 9 182 ratings on the App Store2 and 4.7 from 23 931 reviews on Google Play, where it has over a million downloads.3 App ratings measure the app (search, alerts, saved cars), not the sellers you meet through it, so read them beside the Hellopeter and Google scores above.
How AutoTrader’s rating compares with other car sites
On Hellopeter, the South African review site, the car sites people compare score like this. The number of reviews matters as much as the stars: a score built on thousands of reviews moves less than one built on a handful.
| Site | Stars | Reviews in the rating |
|---|---|---|
| WeBuyCars | 4.8 out of 513 | 16 916 |
| Weelee | 4.3 out of 514 | 700 |
| AutoTrader | 4.3 out of 51 | 40 |
| Cars.co.za | 4.3 out of 515 | 6 |
WeBuyCars and Weelee buy and sell cars themselves, so their reviews are about their own sales; AutoTrader and Cars.co.za are marketplaces, so reviews of a seller belong on that seller’s own profile.
Insure the car before you collect it
AutoTrader’s car insurance page explains how cover works but names no insurer and offers no quote.16 Get your cover in place before you hand over the money, so the policy starts the moment the car is yours. Put the car into the form below for quotes from several insurers, or see how car insurance quotes compare.
Other car marketplaces
- WeBuyCars (We Buy Cars) near me: branches, contact numbers and trading hours
- Cars.co.za contact number, WhatsApp and cars for sale by province
- Weelee cars: contact number, Centurion megastore and buying pods
- Carfind.co.za contact number, cars for sale and selling prices
- Toyota Automark dealers and contact numbers
- Auto Mart contact number, email and dealers