OneCompare

Premium pricing

How Premiums Are Calculated

A car insurance premium is an estimate turned into a monthly figure. The insurer estimates how likely a driver like you is to claim and what those claims would cost, adds its own costs, and then adds the amounts that sit on top of every policy, such as SASRIA and VAT. This guide takes the premium apart in that order, so you can read your own schedule and see which parts you can change.

Insurance Fundamentals

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 29 September 2026 · 6 min read

On this page

The two questions behind every premium

Every rating model comes down to two estimates: how often a car and driver like yours will claim, and how much each claim is likely to cost. Multiply them together and you have the expected cost of claims, often called the risk premium. It is usually the largest part of what you pay.

Thinking in those two halves makes the rating factors easier to follow. Some details change how likely a claim is; others change how expensive it would be. A few change both.

What makes a claim more likely

The driver’s age and how long they have held a licence, their claims history, how the car is used (private, business, or carrying passengers or goods for payment), how far it travels in a year, and the area where it is driven and kept. Each of these is something the insurer can measure against its own records of who claims and how often.

This is why the regular driver and the use of the car have to be declared accurately: they are among the details the insurer priced, and a claim is tested against them.

What makes a claim more expensive

The value of the car and the basis on which it would be settled, the cost of its parts and repairs, and how attractive it is to thieves and hijackers. A car that is expensive to repair or often stolen costs more to insure even with a careful driver.

Some of what you choose lowers the cost of a claim to the insurer. A higher excess means you carry more of each claim. A tracking device improves the chance of recovering a stolen car. Secure overnight parking reduces the chance of theft and damage. Each of those can show in the premium.

What sits on top of the risk premium

The insurer adds its own running costs and a margin for profit. Some policies also carry a policy or administration fee, which is shown on the schedule.

SASRIA cover is usually shown as its own line. SASRIA is the state-owned insurer for damage caused by riots, strikes, public disorder and terrorism, which ordinary motor policies exclude. Premiums also include VAT. Optional extras, such as car hire, credit shortfall or tyre and rim cover, each add their own amount.

Why two insurers quote differently for the same car

Each insurer builds its rating model on its own claims experience, so each weights the same details differently. One may see more theft claims on a particular model; another may have better results with young drivers in a certain area. Insurers also differ in their running costs and in which risks they want more or less of.

That is why the same driver and car can receive quite different quotes, and why comparing quotes on identical, accurate details tells you more than any rule of thumb.

How to read the breakdown on your schedule

Your policy schedule lists what you pay for each section: the vehicle cover, SASRIA, each optional extra and any fee. Go through it line by line and ask yourself whether each item is something you chose and still need. An extra added years ago, such as car hire on a second car you rarely drive, may no longer earn its cost.

Then check the details the premium was built on: the regular driver, the use of the car, where it is kept overnight, the value basis and any tracking condition. If any of them has changed, tell your insurer. A detail that is wrong in your favour is a risk at claim time; one that is wrong against you is costing you money.

When the premium changes

Insurers review premiums at renewal, when they apply their latest claims experience and costs to your details. The premium can also change during the year if you change something material, such as the car, the address, the drivers or the use. Our guide on why car insurance goes up covers renewal increases in detail.

Frequently asked questions

How Premiums Are Calculated — common questions

The insurer estimates how likely a driver and car like yours are to claim and how much those claims would cost, adds its own costs and any fees, then adds SASRIA cover where included and VAT. Each insurer weights the details differently.

SASRIA is the state-owned insurer that covers damage from riots, strikes, public disorder and terrorism, which ordinary motor policies exclude. It is usually shown as a separate line on your schedule with its own small premium.

Because the premium is built on more than the car and the address: the drivers’ ages and records, claims history, use, mileage, parking, value basis, excess and extras all differ between households, and each insurer weights them differently.

Usually, yes. A higher voluntary excess means you carry more of each claim, which lowers the insurer’s expected cost. Set it at an amount you could pay without difficulty if you had to claim.

Get a free policy review

Have questions about this topic?

Upload your policy schedule or claim letter and our team reviews it free of charge — no obligation, no pressure.