OneCompare

Cost · Excess

Car insurance excess explained: how it works on a claim, every type of excess, and how to choose yours

Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email.

Excess is “the first amount you pay when you claim”, in Budget’s words: on a R30,000 repair with a R5,000 excess, you pay R5,000 and the insurer pays R25,000. Most policies carry a basic excess on every claim and add extra excesses in set cases, such as a young driver who isn’t the regular driver, and your schedule lists them.1,2

Checked on 8 November 2026 against insurers’ policy wordings and pages. The amounts that apply to you are on your own policy schedule.

Every kind of car insurance excess, with insurers’ own examples
Type of excessWhat it is, in insurers’ words
Basic (standard)Paid on every claim. OUTsurance: “a fixed excess – irrespective of the nature of your claim”; King Price: an amount “that applies to each specific insured incident/item”2,3
Voluntary or selectedA level you choose: MiWay comprehensive “R5 000 Flexible”; OUTsurance lets you change the excess “within limits”2,4
Young or new driverOUTsurance adds one only “when someone who is younger than 25 and not listed as the regular driver” has an accident; Auto & General when the driver “is not the noted regular driver or spouse”2,5
No trackerOld Mutual Insure: from R500,000 a higher excess or no theft cover, depending on the product, if the required tracker isn’t fitted6
Windscreen and glassNaked, with approval: nothing under R2,000, the amount over R2,000 up to R3,000, then R1,0007
Theft and hijackingDiscovery’s Classic plan: “NO EXCESS” on theft-related and weather-related claims, and on an accident caused by an insured third party8
Percentage of valueMiWay Lite: “10% of insured value at the time of the incident”4
Write-offNo separate write-off excess in the wordings we read; the excess is “the first amount you pay when you claim”, on any claim1

None of the public wordings we read prints the amounts of the additional excesses; they are on each client’s schedule.

How excess works on a claim: a worked example

Your car needs a R30,000 repair and your schedule shows a R5,000 basic excess (MiWay’s comprehensive cover is advertised with a “R5 000 Flexible” excess).4 You pay the R5,000, usually to the repairer, and the insurer pays the other R25,000.

Now add an additional excess. If the driver was under 25 and not the listed regular driver, OUTsurance charges an extra excess on top of the basic one; its amount is on your schedule.2 Two excesses on one claim are paid together.

And if the claim is smaller than the excess, nothing is paid. MiWay’s own example: “If my claimed amount (i.e. R2800) is less than the excess payable (i.e. R4000) on the claim, Miway will not pay my claim.”9

A percentage excess

On MiWay Lite the excess is “10% of insured value at the time of the incident”. On a car insured for R200,000 that is R20,000 (our arithmetic), whatever the claim.4

Compare car insurance quotes at the excess you can afford.

Compare quotes

How each insurer sets the basic excess

  • OUTsurance: a fixed excess whatever the claim, which it will change “within limits”, paid “upfront to the service provider”.2
  • King Price: “Excess is unique for every insurance product and based on your risk profile.”3
  • Budget and Auto & General: “indicated on your schedule”, with any additional excess “added to the basic excess”.1
  • Naked: the basic excess you choose “is the maximum excess you will pay per incident”.7
  • Discovery Insure (Classic): “Choose your own excess”.8
  • Absa idirect: “Fixed excess from as low as R3 000”.10

Is it better to have a high or low excess?

A higher excess lowers the premium; Dialdirect: “Increasing your excess can lower your car insurance premiums.”11 The cost is at claim time: you pay more yourself, and any claim smaller than the excess isn’t paid at all.9

What is a good amount of excess?

One you could pay tomorrow without borrowing, because it is due when you claim, and often to the repairer before you collect the car.2 Published starting points range from Absa idirect’s R3,000 to MiWay’s R5,000 flexible excess.4,10 If you pick a high excess to cut the premium, put the difference aside each month.

Do you pay excess if the accident wasn’t your fault, and can you claim it back?

Yes, you pay it. King Price: “Excess payments are also payable in circumstances where you didn’t cause the accident.” OUTsurance: “You still need to pay the excess even though you did not cause the accident.”3,12

Can I claim my excess back?

If the insurer recovers it from the other side. Budget: “Should your excess be recovered from the other party we will refund this to you.” OUTsurance and King Price refund it too. MiWay says its excess is “non-refundable and the recovery thereof… is not guaranteed”.1,3,9,12

Excess waivers and car insurance with no excess

A few products pay or remove the excess in set cases; none of them removes it on every claim:

  • Discovery Classic: no excess on theft-related and weather-related claims, or when an insured third party caused the accident.8
  • Prime South Africa: on comprehensive and customised cover the excess “reduces every month you don’t claim”, down to zero.13
  • Dotsure: a “cash benefit after a valid claim… Use it to cover your excess”.14
  • FNB: a car rental excess waiver, so “you’ll only pay R4 500 excess”, up to R30,000 per incident.15
  • Naked: no excess on an approved glass claim under R2,000.7

OUTsurance says plainly that it doesn’t offer an excess waiver.2

Is it better to have excess or no excess?

You can’t usually choose none: the basic excess is part of the policy. What you can choose is its level, and extras that pay it in particular claims. Compare the extra premium for those against the excess you would otherwise pay.

Other excesses on your schedule

Some insurers charge their own excess on particular claims. Pineapple charges a separate excess on glass-only claims, and King Price’s scratch and dent cover applies its basic excess to each claim, up to R3,000 a claim.3,16

An older Oneplan guide (March 2020) shows how additional excesses stack: R2,500 per claim, plus 10% for a single-vehicle incident and 10% where the driver had held a licence for under two years, with a minimum of R2,500.17 Read your own schedule for the amounts that apply to you, and see how a claim affects your cash back before you claim for a small amount.

Car insurance excess: questions people ask

The first amount you pay yourself when you claim. On a R30,000 repair with a R5,000 excess, you pay R5,000 and the insurer pays R25,000.

A higher excess lowers your premium, but you pay more when you claim and a claim smaller than the excess isn’t paid. Choose the highest excess you could pay tomorrow without borrowing.

One you can afford at short notice. Published starting points range from R3,000 at Absa idirect to MiWay’s R5,000 flexible excess.

If your insurer recovers it from the driver who caused the accident. Budget, OUTsurance and King Price refund a recovered excess; MiWay says its excess is non-refundable.

Most policies have a basic excess you can’t remove. Some cover pays it in set cases: Discovery Classic charges no excess on theft or weather claims, and Prime’s excess reduces each month you don’t claim.

Sources

  1. Budget Insurance, “Terms and Conditions including Budget Lite”, May 2024. budgetinsurance.co.za
  2. OUTsurance, “Car insurance excess”, read 2 November 2026. outsurance.co.za
  3. King Price, “Personal insurance policy document”, version 09/26. kingprice.co.za
  4. MiWay, “Car insurance”, read 2 November 2026. miway.co.za
  5. Auto & General, “Car insurance”, read 2 November 2026. autogen.co.za
  6. Old Mutual Insure, “Reaffirming our vehicle tracking device and recovery system requirements (broker communication, copy on a broker’s site)”, 16 July 2026. msbia.co.za
  7. Naked, “Naked policy wording – car”, last updated 31 January 2025. docs.naked.insure
  8. Discovery Insure, “Classic plan brochure”, 2026. discovery.co.za
  9. MiWay, “Policy wording – Mipersonal insurance”, updated March 2026. miway-website.cdn.prismic.io
  10. Absa, “Absa idirect insurance”, read 2 November 2026. absa.co.za
  11. Dialdirect, “Car insurance”, read 2 November 2026. dialdirect.co.za
  12. OUTsurance, “Personal policy document”, version V 05.03.25. outsurance.co.za
  13. Prime South Africa, “Car insurance”, read 9 November 2026. prime.co.za
  14. Dotsure, “Car insurance”, read 9 November 2026. dotsure.co.za
  15. FNB, “Car insurance”, read 9 November 2026. fnb.co.za
  16. Pineapple, “Car insurance policy wording (My Ride)”, September 2025. pineapple.co.za
  17. Oneplan, “The Simple Guide to your Car & Household Insurance Policies”, PDF created 12 March 2020. documents.oneplan.co.za

Insurers’ wordings, prices and rules are each insurer’s own published information unless a source says otherwise. They change, so confirm the details in your quote and on your policy schedule. Naming an insurer here does not mean it endorses OneCompare.