Choosing your cover
Comprehensive vs third party car insurance: which to choose
Comprehensive car insurance pays for accident damage to your own car as well as theft, hijacking and the damage you cause to other people’s property. Third party insurance (third party only) pays for nothing but the damage you cause to others, and third party, fire and theft adds the loss of your own car to theft, hijacking or fire.1,2 Third party costs less: Naked advertises third party cover from R70 a month and comprehensive from R300.3 If your car is financed, the lender normally requires comprehensive.4
Updated 12 November 2026 · Reviewed by the OneCompare Editorial team, 12 November 2026
Checked on 12 November 2026 against Naked’s, Budget’s and OUTsurance’s own car insurance pages, and earlier against the insurers’ policy wordings and Old Mutual’s car page (2 November 2026). Prices are the insurers’ advertised starting prices; yours depends on your car, where you live and your driving record.
| What it pays for | Comprehensive | Third party, fire and theft | Third party only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Damage you cause to other people’s property | Yes | Yes | Yes1 |
| Your car stolen or hijacked | Yes | Yes1,2 | No |
| Fire damage to your car | Yes | Yes1 | No |
| Accident damage to your own car | Yes2 | No | No |
| Hail and storm damage | Depends on the insurer: King Price includes hail unless you ask otherwise; Budget only if your schedule says so1,5 | Not at King Price5 | No |
| Lowest advertised price | From R300 a month (Naked)3 | No published starting price found | From R70 a month (Naked)3 |
Injuries to other people aren’t covered by any of the three: in South Africa they go to the Road Accident Fund.2 Prices are each insurer’s own “from” price, seen on 2 November 2026.
The difference between comprehensive and third party insurance
The difference is your own car. Third party only covers the other side: Budget’s wording says you “may only claim for the damage your vehicle caused to other parties’ property” and won’t be paid “if the insured vehicle is damaged or stolen”.1 Comprehensive adds your own car. OUTsurance’s wording reads: “You are covered for accidental damage to your own vehicle as well as damage to other people’s property. Your vehicle is also covered for theft and hijack.”2
So if you cause an accident, comprehensive repairs both cars; third party repairs only the other driver’s. If the other driver is to blame, you can claim from them or their insurer either way. Each level has its own page: comprehensive, third party, fire and theft and third party only.
Comprehensive vs third party, fire and theft
Third party, fire and theft sits in the middle. Budget pays “if it is damaged as a direct result of fire, explosion, lightning or an attempted theft, or if it is stolen”, but not for accident damage.1 OUTsurance calls its version Limited cover: fire, theft and hijack and other people’s property, with “accidental damage to your own vehicle” not covered.2
The details differ between insurers. King Price’s third party, fire and theft covers theft, hijacking and fire but not explosion or storm damage, and Budget offers it only on cars under R250,000.5,6 Compare the policy wordings, not just the name of the cover.
Third party vs comprehensive: is third party cheaper, and what does each cost?
Yes, on the insurers’ advertised prices. Naked advertises third party cover from R70 a month and comprehensive from R300 a month, and its own examples of comprehensive premiums reach R1,536 a month for a 2025 Toyota Hilux.3
| Cover | From, a month | From, a year |
|---|---|---|
| Third party only | R70 | R840 |
| Comprehensive | R300 | R3,600 |
| Difference | R230 | R2,760 |
Naked’s published starting prices; the yearly figures and the difference are our arithmetic.3
Prices checked 12 November 2026
A worked example: is the difference worth it?
At those starting prices, comprehensive costs R2,760 a year more than third party. Over five years that is R13,800, before any increases. Set that against what comprehensive would pay if your own car were written off or stolen: its value, less the excess. On a paid-off car worth R40,000, five years of the difference is about a third of the car’s value; on a car worth R150,000 it is under a tenth. The closer the yearly difference comes to what you could lose, the less comprehensive gives you. These are starting prices, so ask for both levels in the same quote and run the same sum on your own figures.
Ask for comprehensive and third party in the same comparison and see the difference for your car.
Compare quotesWhich is better, comprehensive or third party?
It depends on the car and on what you could pay yourself:
- A financed car: comprehensive, usually. Naked’s wording warns that a car-finance provider “requires that you have comprehensive insurance”.4 Check your finance agreement before you choose less.
- A car you couldn’t repair or replace from savings: comprehensive, because neither third party level repairs your car after an accident you cause.1
- A car often stolen or hijacked: at least third party, fire and theft, which pays if it is stolen.1
- A paid-off, low-value car: third party only can make sense if you could absorb its loss, since it still covers the damage you cause to others.1
| Your car | What the insurers publish | Cover to look at |
|---|---|---|
| Financed, any value | Naked’s wording warns a finance provider “requires that you have comprehensive insurance”; Old Mutual offers third party, fire and theft only if there is no loan on the car4,7 | Comprehensive |
| Paid off, under R250,000 | Budget’s cheaper Lite plans are for “modest budgets, vehicles under R250,000 and cars that are paid off”8 | Comprehensive, or a lower level if you could replace the car |
| Paid off, over five years old, under R150,000 | OUTsurance designs its Essential car insurance for unfinanced cars older than five years and worth less than R150,0009 | A cheaper, limited cover such as OUTsurance Essential, or third party, fire and theft |
| Paid off, and you could replace it from savings | Third party only still covers the damage you cause to others, but not your own car1 | Third party only |
Each row is what an insurer publishes for that kind of car; the right level for you also depends on what you could pay yourself.
Is comprehensive insurance worth it on an older car?
Check what the policy would pay out. OUTsurance lets you insure at retail value, market value (“the average between the vehicle’s retail and trade values”) or a nominated value, and King Price’s decreasing-premium option lowers the premium monthly “as your car loses value”.2,5 Compare that payout, less the excess, with the yearly difference in premium between the two levels.
Comprehensive or third party? Answer three questions
Three questions decide most cases: whether the car is financed, whether you could replace it yourself, and what it is worth. The answer links to the page for that cover.
Answer the questions to see which cover to look at.
How it decides:
- Financed: comprehensive.
- Paid off, but you couldn’t replace it: comprehensive.
- Paid off, you could replace it, worth R150,000 or more: third party, fire and theft.
- Paid off, you could replace it, worth under R150,000: third party only.
A rule of thumb, not advice: compare quotes for both levels on your own car.
How much each level pays the other side
Comprehensive and third party both pay for what you damage of other people’s, and on both that payment stops at a limit on your schedule. The limit is set per policy, not per level, so a cheaper cover can come with a lower ceiling. These are the figures two insurers publish:
| Insurer and cover | Pays the other side up to |
|---|---|
| OUTsurance comprehensive | R5 million, which it says is extendable |
| OUTsurance Essential | R1 million |
| MiWay comprehensive | R5,000,000 |
| MiWay Lite | R2,500,000 |
| MiWay total loss cover | R250,000, for other people’s movable property only |
A crash that costs more than your limit leaves the rest with you: Auto & General’s own third party example says that you pay the difference. That is the reason to check the limit, not just the level, when you compare a cheap third party quote with comprehensive.11
The excess on each level
On comprehensive you usually pick the excess: OUTsurance lets you choose it, and MiWay’s comprehensive cover carries a R5,000 flexible amount. MiWay’s cheaper Lite cover sets it as “10% of insured value at the time of the incident”, which grows with the car’s value.9,10,12 Ask for the excess on both levels in the same quote, because a low premium with a high excess can cost more on the day you claim.
Moving from comprehensive to third party: what to check first
- The loan is settled. Until it is, the lender sets the cover: as Naked puts it, “if your car is financed, your bank will usually require comprehensive cover.”13
- What comprehensive would pay you now. A written-off or stolen car is paid at the value on your policy, less the excess, so compare that figure with the yearly saving from the worked example above.9
- Whether theft is your bigger worry. If it is, third party, fire and theft keeps the car covered when it is stolen or hijacked, for less than comprehensive.1
- The limit and the excess on the new cover. Cheaper cover can carry a lower third-party limit and a different excess, as the table above shows.10
What neither comprehensive nor third party covers
Injuries to other people: OUTsurance’s wording says liability for death and bodily injury “is covered by the Road Accident Fund inside South Africa”.2 Paid transport: OUTsurance excludes “taxi purposes”, King Price “transporting of fare-paying passengers”, and MiWay “carrying fare-paying passengers (like taxi or shuttle services), delivery services”.2,5,14 If you drive for an e-hailing app or deliver, tell the insurer and ask for cover that includes it.