OneCompare

Your first claim

Filing your first claim

A first claim feels unfamiliar, but every car claim follows the same order: you report it, the insurer opens a claim, an assessor looks at the car, the insurer decides, and the car is repaired or paid out. Knowing that order in advance makes it easier to have the right things ready and to avoid the few mistakes that cause trouble.

Claims & Disputes

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 5 June 2026 · 6 min read

On this page

Before you call: what to have ready

Your policy number, the car’s registration, the date, time and place of the incident, the accident report number from the police, and the other driver’s details if another car was involved. Add your photographs and a short account of what happened, written down while you still remember it clearly.

If the car was stolen or hijacked, have the case number, both sets of keys and the tracking company’s details. If it is financed, have the bank’s name and your account number, because the bank will have to give a settlement figure.

Step 1: report the claim and get a claim number

Report the claim by phone, app or email within the time your policy sets, and as soon as you can. The insurer opens a claim and gives you a claim number. Put it on every email and document from then on, and write down the name of each person you speak to and the date.

Give the same account every time you are asked. Small differences between what you told the call centre, the assessor and the police are one of the things insurers look at most closely.

Step 2: the assessor inspects

For accident damage, the insurer sends an assessor or asks you to take the car to an approved repairer for an assessment. The assessor checks that the damage matches your account and works out what the repair should cost. Do not start repairs before this, apart from what is needed to make the car safe, because the damage is the evidence.

Step 3: the decision

The insurer then authorises a repair, declares the car a write-off, or rejects the claim. A write-off is settled on the value basis shown on your schedule, such as retail or market value, so it is worth knowing which basis you have before you ever need it.

If the claim is rejected, the Policyholder Protection Rules require the insurer to give you its reasons in writing, and you have at least 90 days to make representations to it with anything it did not consider. Our guide to disputing a declined claim explains what to do.

Step 4: the excess

On a repair you usually pay the excess to the repairer when you collect the car; on a write-off or theft it is deducted from the settlement. More than one excess can apply to one claim, for example a basic excess and an additional excess for a young driver, so ask the insurer for the total before the work starts.

Step 5: repair or settlement

For a repair, the repairer orders parts and does the work the insurer authorised, and you collect the car once it is done. For a write-off, the insurer pays the bank first if the car is financed and pays you any balance, and the damaged car becomes the insurer’s. A hired car in the meantime is paid for only if car hire is on your schedule.

Frequently asked questions

Filing your first claim — common questions

Your policy sets the time limit for reporting a claim to your own insurer, and it is often short, so report as soon as you can. A claim against the other driver for damage they caused is a different matter: under the Prescription Act it generally prescribes three years after the accident.

Reporting the claim and getting a claim number, the assessment of the damage, the insurer’s decision to repair, write off or reject, and finally the repair or the settlement, with your excess paid along the way.

Get a free policy review

Have questions about this topic?

Upload your policy schedule or claim letter and our team reviews it free of charge — no obligation, no pressure.