OneCompare

After the accident

Insurance after an accident

The roadside steps are over and the car is home or at a panel beater. What follows is slower and easier to get wrong: deciding whether to claim, living with the repair or the write-off, and seeing the accident on your next renewal and on every insurance application after it. This guide takes those in order.

Claims & Disputes

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 25 September 2026 · 7 min read

On this page

Tell your insurer, even if you may not claim

Car policies normally require you to report any accident that could lead to a claim, by you or against you, within the time the policy sets. Reporting is not the same as claiming. If the other driver decides weeks later to claim from you, an insurer that was told at the time can deal with it; one that was never told can refuse to.

For the same reason, do not agree with the other driver to settle privately, admit liability or promise to pay without your insurer’s consent. Policies usually forbid it, and a private deal can leave you paying for both cars.

Claim, or pay for it yourself?

Start with the repair quote and your excess. If the repair costs little more than the excess, the claim would pay you very little, and it could still cost you a no-claim bonus and count against you at renewal. If the repair costs many times the excess, a claim is what the policy is for.

Paying yourself is only an option when nobody else is involved. Once another car, a wall or a person has been damaged, let your insurer handle it, because a third party can claim against you long after your own repair is done. Our guide to car insurance excess explains how the excess is worked out on a claim.

Your premium and no-claim bonus

A claim usually reaches your premium at renewal rather than on the day. How much depends on the insurer: many reduce or reset the no-claim bonus after a claim, and some treat a claim differently once they have recovered their costs from a driver who was to blame. Ask how your claim has been recorded, and if you were not at fault, ask the insurer to confirm that in writing once its recovery is complete.

While the car is being repaired

The insurer’s assessor inspects the damage and authorises the repair, usually at a repairer the insurer approves. Do not start repairs before that authorisation. A hired car while yours is off the road is paid for only if car hire is on your schedule, and only for the period it states.

When you collect the car, check the repair in daylight: panel gaps, paint colour, lights, warning lamps on the dashboard. Report anything wrong to the insurer before you sign off, and keep the repairer’s written warranty on the work with your policy documents.

If the car is written off

The insurer settles on the value basis on your schedule, less your excess, and pays the bank first if the car is financed. The damaged car becomes the insurer’s salvage, and cover on it ends. Arrange cover on the replacement car before you drive it, not after. Our guide to the write-off decision explains how insurers decide between repair and write-off.

The next time you apply for insurance

Insurance applications ask about previous claims and accidents, usually over a stated number of years. Answer fully and accurately, including claims you think were not your fault. Under section 53 of the Short-term Insurance Act, an insurer can reject a claim over a wrong or missing answer that would have mattered to a reasonable, prudent person assessing the risk, so an accident left off a form can cost far more than it would have added to the premium.

You can move to another insurer after a claim, but the new insurer will see the claim on your application and price it. Compare quotes with the claim declared on every one of them, so that you are comparing like with like.

If you weren’t insured when it happened, see what happens after an accident without insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Insurance after an accident — common questions

Usually not on the day. Most insurers reflect a claim at renewal, through the no-claim bonus and the claims history they price on. Ask your insurer how it has recorded your claim, especially if another driver was to blame.

Get a free policy review

Have questions about this topic?

Upload your policy schedule or claim letter and our team reviews it free of charge — no obligation, no pressure.