Why published averages disagree
An average premium in an article or an advert is usually built from a sample: one car, one driver, one suburb, one excess, and sometimes one insurer’s own customers. Change the car from a small hatchback to a double-cab bakkie, the driver from a middle-aged motorist with a clean record to a newly licensed teenager, or the address from a secure complex to a street where cars are often stolen, and the figure moves a long way.
That is why averages from careful sources still differ, and why none of them is a price for your car. Read any published figure as one example, check which sample it describes, and plan with a quote worked out on your own details.
Inflation was low in 2025; repair bills follow their own costs
Stats SA reported that consumer inflation averaged 3.2% in 2025, the lowest annual average since 2004. That figure does not set car insurance premiums. A motor insurer’s costs are the parts, paint, labour, towing and car hire it pays for on claims, and the cars it replaces after a theft or a write-off. Those follow the prices of vehicles and parts rather than the general price level, and because many parts are imported, a weaker rand raises them too.
Repairs are also getting more complex. In July 2026 the South African Motor Body Repairers’ Association (Sambra) warned that repairability was becoming one of the motor industry’s biggest affordability challenges, for petrol, diesel, hybrid and electric cars alike: with sensors and cameras built into panels, damage that looks minor can sometimes mean replacing a whole assembly rather than a single part.
Fewer carjackings this year
SAPS crime statistics for April to June 2026 recorded 3,811 carjackings, 18.2% fewer than the 4,657 recorded a year earlier.
A better quarter does not reach premiums straight away. Insurers set their rates from their own claims over longer periods, theft and hijacking risk still differs sharply from one suburb to the next, and a model that syndicates target stays a target whatever the national figure does. If your policy requires a tracker, keep it working and paid up, and keep the overnight address on your schedule accurate.
What happens at renewal
Each insurer reviews its own rates, and your renewal letter shows the premium for the coming year. Part of any change may be the insurer’s general rate adjustment and part may be about you: a claim in the past year, a new address, a new regular driver or an updated value for the car. Ask the insurer which part is which before you accept it.
Then get a fresh quote on the same details. The insurer that renews you at a higher premium is not necessarily the dearest choice for the year ahead, and one that quotes lower is only cheaper if its cover matches.
Comparing quotes so the cheaper one really is cheaper
Put quotes side by side on the same car, the same regular driver, the same overnight address and the same type of cover. Then check the things that change what you would pay without changing the headline premium: the excess, including any additional excess for young or newly licensed drivers; whether the car is insured for retail or market value; whether a tracker is a condition of cover; and which extras, such as car hire or windscreen cover, are included.
With OneCompare you enter your details once and see quotes from more than one insurer, so every quote starts from the same facts. That quote, rather than a published average, is the figure to budget with.