Tracker comparison
Tracker vs Cartrack: prices, packages, recovery rates and which tracker is better for your car
Tracker and Cartrack are two separate companies. Tracker publishes its car plans from R139 a month for Recover to R229 for CarePulse, and Cartrack starts from R99 a month with free installation, quoting the rest.1,2,3 On recovery, Tracker reports a 96% recovery rate for its past financial year and Cartrack an audited rate of about 92% to 93%, both their own figures.4,5 Both are on Old Mutual Insure’s list of approved tracker brands.6
Checked on 29 and 30 October 2026 against Tracker’s and Cartrack’s own plan pages, adverts and filings, Hellopeter, VESA’s lists and insurers’ published tracker rules. OneCompare compares tracker quotes; prices change, so check the current price in your quote.
| What | Tracker | Cartrack |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Tracker Connect; marked 30 years in October 20264,7 | Part of Karooooo Ltd (Nasdaq and JSE) since April 2021; founded in 20018,9 |
| Car tracking prices | Recover R139, Protect R179, Care R199, CarePulse R229 a month1 | From R99 a month with free installation; package prices of R189, R289 and R389 on its own blog2,10 |
| Recovery rate (its own claim) | 96% in its past financial year; 142,253 vehicles recovered since it started4 | “Approximately 92% to 93%”, audited; over 100,000 vehicles in a decade5 |
| Hellopeter, 12 months | 3.8 out of 5 from 1,207 reviews; TrustIndex 8.4; 2nd in vehicle tracking7 | 4.3 out of 5 from 20,841 reviews; TrustIndex 9.2; 1st in vehicle tracking7 |
| On VESA’s supplier list | No11 | No11 |
| Old Mutual Insure approved brand | Yes6 | Yes6 |
| Emergency number | 080 013 232312 | 011 250 300013 |
Each company’s figures are its own published information, seen on 29 and 30 October 2026; Hellopeter’s scores are as Hellopeter showed them on 29 October 2026.
Tracker vs Cartrack prices: what each costs per month
Tracker lists five car plans on its own site. Response, from R69 a month, is a crash-detection plan that alerts emergency help after an accident. Recover, from R139, is the first plan Tracker describes with theft recovery; Protect, from R179, adds early-warning alerts; Care, from R199, adds roadside and medical assistance; and CarePulse, from R229, is its full package with “full emergency support”.1
Cartrack doesn’t put a price list on its pricing page: you ask for a quote. Its own blog says “Cartrack packages starts from R99.00 per month”, and its adverts offer tracking “from just R99 PM with FREE installation”.2,3 A Cartrack comparison post shows package prices of R189, R289 and R389 a month, and AutoTrader reported Cartrack at R149 to R260 a month on subscription, or about R199 to R335 on a 36-month rental.10,14
Is Cartrack cheaper than Tracker?
At the entry level, yes: Cartrack’s advertised R99 a month is R40 less than Tracker’s Recover plan at R139.1,3 Further up, the two overlap, and what you pay depends on the package, the contract and any fitting fee in your quote, so compare the full monthly price for your car rather than the advertised “from” price.
Before you sign a tracker contract, see what Tracker, Cartrack and others cost for your car.
Get tracker quotesTracker vs Cartrack packages: what you get on each
Tracker’s plans step up from recovery to assistance. Recover lets you see the car in the Tracker Connect app and includes theft retrieval: “one call to our National Emergency Control Centre will allow us to track and recover your vehicle anywhere within South Africa.” Care adds roadside and medical assistance and early-warning alerts.1,15 Tracker also offers a Subscription Waiver: if the car is written off with no replacement, it says it will settle the rest of the Tracker subscription.15
Cartrack lists vehicle recovery, crash detection, CarWatch alerts if the car moves without your consent, a logbook for SARS, and Protector, an add-on with medical, roadside and legal help at the push of a button.16 Cartrack says its stolen vehicle recovery and 24/7 control room “are included in all our solutions”, and that its devices carry a 12-month warranty.2
What does the Cartrack R99 package include?
Cartrack’s R99 adverts promise “Backup signal protection”, “Live vehicle tracking” and a “Recovery team on standby 24/7”, with free installation.3 Cartrack doesn’t publish a list of what each price includes, so ask the consultant which features your quote covers before you sign.
Cartrack vs Tracker recovery rates compared
Tracker reported recovering 142,253 vehicles and helping with 21,461 arrests since it started, and “a 96% industry recovery rate in the past financial year”, in figures it released for its 30th year.4 Cartrack says it has recovered “over 100 000 vehicles” in the past decade and has “an audited recovery rate of approximately 92% to 93%”.5,17 Its recovery-rate page doesn’t name the auditor or the period.
Both rates are the companies’ own, measured their own way, so the gap between them doesn’t show that one recovers more cars than the other. VESA, the industry’s standards body, suggests asking any tracking company whether its recovery statistics are “independently audited by a 3rd party”.18
Which is better, Tracker or Cartrack?
It depends on what you need from the tracker. On the published facts:
- Lowest entry price: Cartrack, from R99 a month with free installation, against Tracker’s Recover at R139.1,3
- Roadside and medical help: both sell it, as Tracker Care and CarePulse and as Cartrack’s Protector add-on.1,16
- Reviews: Hellopeter ranked Cartrack first and Tracker second in vehicle tracking on 29 October 2026, with Cartrack on 4.3 out of 5 from 20,841 reviews and Tracker on 3.8 from 1,207.7
- Your insurer: Old Mutual Insure names both brands as approved, so either can meet that insurer’s rule if the unit has the features your schedule asks for.6
Cartrack complaints and the National Consumer Commission
In March 2026 Cartrack agreed to settle 167 consumer complaints “without admission of liability”, paying a R5 million administrative fine and refunding R5,101,225 to consumers. The National Consumer Commission said some of its sale terms were inconsistent with the Consumer Protection Act, and Cartrack undertook to cancel affected contracts without a cancellation fee and to amend its terms.19 Read the contract’s cancellation terms with either company before you sign. Already signed and want out? See how to cancel a tracker contract.
Are Cartrack and Tracker the same company?
No. Cartrack has belonged since April 2021 to Karooooo Ltd, which is listed on the Nasdaq and the JSE, and Zak Calisto founded Cartrack in 2001.8,9 Karooooo reported 2,005,888 Cartrack subscribers in South Africa at 28 February 2026.20 Cartrack also runs its own insurance agency, Cartrack Insurance Agency, FSP 17266, which places car insurance with insurers.21
Tracker trades as Tracker Connect and marked 30 years in October 2026.4,7 The two have separate control rooms, emergency numbers and contracts.
Will my insurer accept Tracker or Cartrack?
Insurers set the rule by the device and its features, not usually by brand. Old Mutual Insure is the one insurer that publishes a brand list, and it names Tracker and Cartrack among others; it requires an early-warning tracker on cars worth R1.5 million or more and on the models on its high-theft list.6 Hollard says any tracking company will do if the device meets its requirements, and its Hollard Prestige wording accepts a radio-frequency or an early-warning device, asking for two on some high-risk models.22,23
Neither Tracker nor Cartrack was on VESA’s list of tracking product suppliers when we checked, but VESA says its membership is voluntary.11,24 What counts is your policy schedule: it says which kind of tracker your car needs. Our guide to when an insurer requires a tracker explains the rules.
Tracker and Cartrack emergency numbers
- Tracker: 080 013 2323, its 24-hour emergency line; roadside assistance is 086 111 8729.12
- Cartrack: 011 250 3000, the emergency number on every page of its site.13
Call the tracking company first if the car is stolen or hijacked, then report it to the police and your insurer. Our guide to what happens after a theft covers the insurance side.
Tracker and Cartrack against Netstar
If Netstar is also on your list, our other side-by-side pages compare it with each: