OneCompare

Tracker comparison

Cartrack vs Netstar: prices, packages, recovery rates and which tracker is better for your car

Get tracker quotes →Compare tracker prices for your car, fitting included.

Cartrack and Netstar are separate companies with similar entry prices. Netstar publishes four car packages, from R89 a month for STARtag to R199 for Early Warning, and Cartrack starts from R99 a month with free installation, quoting the rest.1,2,3 Cartrack reports an audited recovery rate of about 92% to 93% and Netstar a rate of over 90%, both their own figures.4,5 Old Mutual Insure names both as approved tracker brands.6

Checked on 29 and 30 October 2026 against Cartrack’s and Netstar’s own plan pages, adverts and filings, Hellopeter, VESA’s lists and insurers’ published tracker rules. OneCompare compares tracker quotes; prices change, so check the current price in your quote.

Cartrack vs Netstar at a glance, 2026
WhatCartrackNetstar
OwnerKarooooo Ltd, listed on the Nasdaq and the JSE7Altron, listed on the JSE8
Car tracking pricesFrom R99 a month with free installation; quote for the rest2,3STARtag R89, Basic R139, Plus R169, Early Warning R199 a month1
ContractSubscription or 36-month rental, AutoTrader reported936-month rental, no upfront payment9
Recovery rate (its own claim)“Approximately 92% to 93%”, audited4Over 90%5
Subscribers2,005,888 in South Africa at 28 February 2026, in a filing10“More than 2.2 million”, Netstar says5
Hellopeter, 12 months4.3 out of 5 from 20,841 reviews; TrustIndex 9.2; 1st in vehicle tracking112 out of 5 from 963 reviews; TrustIndex 4.7; 3rd in vehicle tracking11
On VESA’s supplier listNo12Yes12
Emergency number011 250 3000130800 11 22 2214

Each company’s figures are its own published information, seen on 29 and 30 October 2026, except Cartrack’s subscriber count, which is from its parent’s filing; Hellopeter’s scores are as Hellopeter showed them on 29 October 2026.

Cartrack vs Netstar prices: what each costs per month

Netstar publishes its four car packages: STARtag at R89 a month, Basic at R139, Plus at R169 and Early Warning at R199.1 Cartrack shows no price list on its pricing page and quotes instead; its blog says its packages start from R99 a month, and a Cartrack comparison post shows packages at R189, R289 and R389.2,13,15

AutoTrader reported Netstar’s packages on a 36-month rental with no upfront payment, and Cartrack at R149 to R260 a month on subscription or about R199 to R335 on a 36-month rental.9

Is Netstar cheaper than Cartrack?

At the very bottom, yes: Netstar’s STARtag, a wireless unit, is R89 a month against Cartrack’s R99 starting price.1,3 Netstar’s cheapest hardwired package, Basic, is R139. Netstar fits at your home or office or at more than 100 fitment centres, and Cartrack advertises free installation.3,16 Netstar’s current advert offers Early Warning at R199 a month with a free STARtag as a backup device.17

Before you sign a tracker contract, see what Cartrack, Netstar and others cost for your car.

Get tracker quotes

Cartrack vs Netstar packages: what you get on each

Every Netstar package includes stolen vehicle recovery, a fitment certificate and the MyNetstar app. Basic adds theft, tamper, impact and battery-disconnect alerts; Plus adds live tracking, a driver-behaviour score and a SARS logbook; Early Warning adds an early-warning theft alert, auto-arm, a proximity tag and a panic button.1

Cartrack lists vehicle recovery, crash detection, CarWatch alerts if the car moves without your consent, a SARS logbook and Protector, an add-on for medical, roadside and legal help at the push of a button. It says stolen vehicle recovery and its 24/7 control room come with every package.2,18

Do Cartrack and Netstar have anti-jamming?

Both say so. Netstar’s JammingResist, on Basic and up, sends you an SMS when someone tries to block the tracking signal. Cartrack’s adverts say its anti-jamming technology “detects signal interference, switches to a backup signal”.1,3

Netstar vs Cartrack recovery rates compared

Cartrack says it has “an audited recovery rate of approximately 92% to 93%” and has recovered over 100,000 vehicles in the past decade; its recovery-rate page doesn’t name the auditor or the period.4,19 Netstar says it recovers over 90% of vehicles, in about 40 minutes, and that recovery is free while your account is up to date.5,14

Each company measures its own rate, so the figures can’t be set side by side as a test of which finds more cars. VESA suggests asking whether a supplier’s recovery statistics are “independently audited by a 3rd party”.20

Which is better, Cartrack or Netstar?

Neither wins on every count. On the published facts:

  • Cheapest entry: Netstar’s STARtag at R89 a month; Cartrack from R99.1,3
  • A published price list: Netstar shows all four package prices; Cartrack quotes.1,13
  • Reviews: on Hellopeter, Cartrack was first in vehicle tracking with a TrustIndex of 9.2 from 20,841 reviews, and Netstar third with 4.7 from 963.11
  • VESA: Netstar is on VESA’s list of tracking product suppliers and Cartrack isn’t.12

Common complaints about Cartrack

The National Consumer Commission received complaints from 210 Cartrack customers, many saying Cartrack failed to provide remedies. Cartrack settled 167 of them in March 2026 without admitting liability, with a R5 million fine, refunds and a promise to cancel affected contracts without a cancellation fee.21 If you want to leave either company, see how to cancel a tracker contract.

Who owns Cartrack and Netstar?

Cartrack has belonged to Karooooo Ltd since April 2021, and Zak Calisto founded Cartrack in 2001. Karooooo reported 2,005,888 Cartrack subscribers in South Africa at 28 February 2026.7,10,22

Netstar is owned by the JSE-listed Altron group and has been led by Warren Mande since July 2026; Netstar says it serves more than 2.2 million subscribers and dates itself to 1994.5,8,23

Will my insurer accept Cartrack or Netstar?

Old Mutual Insure names both among its approved brands and requires an early-warning tracker on cars worth R1.5 million or more and on its high-theft models; Netstar’s Early Warning package is that kind of unit.1,6 Hollard says any tracking company will do if the device meets its requirements.24

Netstar (Pty) Ltd is a VESA supplier member, though the one Netstar unit on VESA’s approved-equipment list is a fleet-management unit.12,25 Your policy schedule says which kind of tracker your car needs; our guide to insurer-approved trackers explains how insurers word it.

Cartrack and Netstar emergency numbers

  • Cartrack: 011 250 3000.13
  • Netstar: 0800 11 22 22, its Emergency Call Centre; the customer line is 0860 12 24 36.14,26

Call the tracking company first, then report the theft to the police and your insurer. See what happens after a theft.

Cartrack and Netstar against Tracker

Comparing a third brand? Our other side-by-side pages:

Questions people ask about Cartrack and Netstar

Neither on every count. Netstar starts cheaper, at R89 a month, publishes all its prices and is on VESA’s supplier list; Cartrack starts at R99 with free installation and ranked first on Hellopeter in October 2026. Both are on Old Mutual Insure’s approved list.

At the entry level, by R10: Netstar’s wireless STARtag is R89 a month and Cartrack starts at R99. Netstar’s hardwired packages run from R139 to R199, and Cartrack quotes its other packages.

From R99 a month with free installation, Cartrack says. It quotes the rest; its own comparison post shows packages at R189, R289 and R389, and AutoTrader reported R149 to R260 on subscription.

Cartrack says it has an audited recovery rate of approximately 92% to 93% and has recovered over 100,000 vehicles in the past decade. It doesn’t name the auditor.

Karooooo Ltd, which has owned Cartrack since April 2021 and is listed on the Nasdaq and the JSE. Zak Calisto founded Cartrack in 2001.

The National Consumer Commission received complaints from 210 Cartrack customers, many about remedies not being given. Cartrack settled 167 in March 2026 without admitting liability, paid a R5 million fine and refunded customers.

Both say they do. Netstar’s JammingResist, on Basic and higher, sends an SMS if the signal is blocked; Cartrack says its anti-jamming detects interference and switches to a backup signal.

011 250 3000, shown on every page of Cartrack’s site. Netstar’s Emergency Call Centre is 0800 11 22 22.

Further reading

A separate look at how the main South African providers differ, written from the tracking side rather than the insurance side.

comparing the major tracking providers

MiTrekker is our specialist vehicle tracking and dashcam comparison site.

Sources

  1. Netstar, “Personal plans (STARtag, Basic, Plus, Early Warning)”, read 29 and 30 October 2026. netstar.co.za
  2. Cartrack, “How much does a car tracking device cost now?”, published 20 August 2024, modified 8 April 2026. cartrack.co.za
  3. Get It Back by Cartrack (Meta advert), “Anti-jamming advert, Ad Library ID 960357473731399”, started 11 August 2026, seen 30 October 2026. facebook.com
  4. Cartrack, “Cartrack’s reviews: questions and answers”, no date shown, read 29 October 2026. cartrack.co.za
  5. Netstar, “About Netstar”, read 29 October 2026. netstar.co.za
  6. Old Mutual Insure, “Reaffirming our vehicle tracking device and recovery system requirements (broker communication, copy on a broker’s site)”, 16 July 2026. msbia.co.za
  7. Cartrack, “Investor relations”, no date shown, read 29 October 2026. cartrack.co.za
  8. TechCentral, “Netstar turns vehicle tracking into a data play”, 10 June 2026. techcentral.co.za
  9. AutoTrader, “Which car tracker is best for South Africans?”, 23 February 2026. autotrader.co.za
  10. Karooooo Ltd (Cartrack’s parent), “Form 6-K, results to 28 February 2026”, 13 May 2026. karooooo.gcs-web.com
  11. Hellopeter, “Vehicle tracking companies”, read 29 October 2026. hellopeter.com
  12. VESA, “Find a product supplier member (tracking and recovery)”, read 29 October 2026. vesa.co.za
  13. Cartrack, “See plans and pricing”, read 29 and 30 October 2026. cartrack.co.za
  14. Netstar, “FAQ”, read 29 October 2026. netstar.co.za
  15. Cartrack, “Compare car tracking devices: finding the best fit for you”, published 13 January 2025, modified 22 September 2026. cartrack.co.za
  16. Netstar, “Car tracker prices”, modified 24 June 2024. go.netstar.co.za
  17. Netstar, “Meta Ad Library, ad 1110927818365990: “Netstar vehicle tracking and recovery for just R199pm + FREE STARtag backup device. T&Cs apply.””, started 30 October 2026, seen 30 October 2026. facebook.com
  18. Cartrack, “Car tracking for me and my family”, no date shown, read 29 October 2026. cartrack.co.za
  19. Cartrack, “Audited recovery rate”, no date shown, read 29 October 2026. cartrack.co.za
  20. VESA, “Product levels and descriptions”, read 30 October 2026. vesa.co.za
  21. National Consumer Commission, “Cartrack agrees to settle 167 complaints”, 27 March 2026. thencc.org.za
  22. Forbes Africa, “Engine of growth: a South African entrepreneur on scaling to 23 countries”, 9 January 2025. forbesafrica.com
  23. BusinessDay, “Warren Mande to take the helm at Netstar from July”, 16 April 2026. businessday.co.za
  24. The Hollard Insurance Company, “Tracking device requirement FAQs (copy on a broker’s site)”, March 2023. xenturion.co.za
  25. VESA, “ABS-approved equipment”, read 29 October 2026. vesa.co.za
  26. Netstar, “Contact us”, read 30 October 2026. netstar.co.za

Prices, plans and figures are each company’s own published information unless a source says otherwise. They change, so confirm the current price in your quote and your insurer’s tracker rule on your policy schedule. Naming a company here does not mean it endorses OneCompare.