OneCompare

Paid in cash

Insurance for cash buyers

When you pay cash for a car, nobody else has a say in how it is insured. There is no bank to insist on comprehensive cover, no bank noted on the policy and no bank paid first if the car is written off. That freedom is useful, but it also means the whole loss is yours if you choose the wrong cover. Here is what changes, and what to check.

Money & Financial

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 17 November 2026 · 5 min read

On this page

You choose the level of cover

A financed car normally has to be comprehensively insured. A car you own outright can have comprehensive cover, third party, fire and theft, or third-party only, and the right answer depends on what you could afford to lose: the whole car to theft, the cost of repairing it after an accident, or neither. Our guide to choosing between comprehensive and third-party cover works through it question by question.

Whatever you choose, keep liability cover. Damage you cause to someone else’s car or property can cost far more than your own car is worth, and third-party liability is part of every level of cover.

Buying cash at an auction

Car auctions are a common place to pay cash, and the auction houses ask for money up front before you bid. WeBuyCars auctions charge a R4 000 registration fee for each car you bid on, refunded if no sale is concluded, and Weelee auctions take a R3 000 refundable deposit that is forfeited if you win and don't pay in full within 48 hours. Arrange the insurance quote before the auction ends, so cover starts the day the car becomes yours.

The settlement comes to you

With no bank noted on the policy, a theft or write-off settlement is paid to you, less your excess. You have no finance balance to clear first, so you have no need for credit shortfall cover either: it exists only to pay the gap between a settlement and what is owed to a lender.

Get the value basis right

Because the whole settlement is yours, the value basis on your schedule matters more than ever. Retail value, market value and agreed value can pay quite different amounts for the same car. Ask the insurer what figure it would pay for your car today, and compare it with what it would cost you to buy a similar car.

Keep proof that the car is yours

An insurer pays the owner, so make sure the car is registered in your name and keep the purchase invoice or agreement of sale with the registration certificate. If you bought privately, register the change of ownership promptly, because until you do, the records still show the seller as owner.

If you decide to carry the risk yourself

Choosing third-party only on a car you could replace is a reasonable decision, provided you really could replace it. If you go that way, put aside each month what the extra cover would have cost, so that the money is there when the car is damaged or stolen. Review the decision every year, because a car you could replace this year may not be one you could replace next year.

If you finance instead, the bank sets the rules; see insurance for a financed car.

Choosing no cover at all? See what happens after an accident without insurance.

Get a free policy review

Have questions about this topic?

Upload your policy schedule or claim letter and our team reviews it free of charge — no obligation, no pressure.