OneCompare

Claims · Third-party claims

How to claim from someone else’s car insurance in South Africa

Compare car insurance quotes →One form; your quotes by email.

How to claim from someone else’s insurance, in short: when another driver damages your car, you claim on someone else’s insurance by sending their insurer a third-party claim, with proof they were at fault, your repair quotes and the accident report number. If they have no insurer, you claim from the driver personally: a letter of demand, then the Small Claims Court for up to R30,000 since 1 August 2026.1 Injuries go to the Road Accident Fund, not to car insurance.

Updated 14 November 2026 · Reviewed by the OneCompare Editorial team, 14 November 2026

Checked on 14 November 2026 against the National Road Traffic Act, the Prescription Act, the Road Accident Fund Act, SAnews and the Department of Justice’s Small Claims Court guide. General information, not legal advice.

Your routes when someone else damages your car
RouteWhenWho pays youWatch out for
Claim from their insurerThe other driver was to blame and has insuranceTheir insurer, once it accepts faultIt asks its own client first, so allow time
Claim on your own policyYou have comprehensive coverYour insurer, which then recovers from themYou pay your excess first
Claim from the driverThey have no insurance, or their insurer refusesThe driver, after a letter of demandThe Small Claims Court takes claims up to R30,0001
InjuriesAnyone was hurtThe Road Accident Fund2The RAF pays for injury and death, not car damage

A claim against the other driver generally prescribes three years after the accident, under the Prescription Act.3

How to claim from the other driver’s insurance, step by step

  1. At the scene: get the other driver’s name, ID number, phone number, address, registration number, insurer and, if they have it, policy number; if they aren’t the owner, the owner’s details too. The Road Traffic Act obliges a driver involved in an accident to give their name and address, the owner’s name and address and the licence number when asked on reasonable grounds.4
  2. Report it: if it wasn’t reported to a police or traffic officer at the scene, report it at a police station within 24 hours if anyone was killed or injured, or otherwise on the first working day after the accident, and keep the case or accident report number.4
  3. Gather evidence: photographs of both cars and the scene, witness names and numbers, and dash cam footage if you have it.
  4. Get quotes: written repair quotes from reputable repairers; insurers often ask for more than one.
  5. Send the claim: write to the other insurer’s claims department with the documents below, and keep proof of when you sent it.
  6. Follow up in writing: note the claim reference and ask for a decision; don’t authorise repairs on the assumption it will pay until it has said so in writing.

How long that takes depends on the insurer; see how long a car insurance claim takes.

Without comprehensive cover, you carry this yourself. Compare car insurance quotes.

Compare quotes

The third party claim procedure in South Africa

A third-party claim is a claim against the person who caused the damage, or against their insurer. The other insurer asks its own client for their version before it decides. It may accept the claim, send an assessor to see your car, offer part payment if it believes both drivers were partly to blame, or reject it. Its duty to pay is owed to its own client, so if it refuses, your claim lies against the driver who caused the accident.

Injuries: the Road Accident Fund

The Road Accident Fund compensates people for loss caused by bodily injury or death from the driving of a motor vehicle where another driver was negligent or acted wrongfully; it doesn’t pay for damage to cars.2 Claims for injuries go to the RAF directly, separately from the claim for your car.

Documents for a third party insurance claim

  • The police case or accident report number
  • The other driver’s and owner’s details, and their insurer and policy number
  • Photographs of the damage and the scene, and any dash cam footage
  • Written repair quotes
  • A copy of your driving licence and your car’s registration papers
  • Witness statements, and an affidavit setting out what happened if the insurer asks for one
  • Towing and storage invoices, if you paid them

A third party affidavit is a sworn statement of how the accident happened; the police station where you report the accident, or a commissioner of oaths, can take it.

The letter to the other insurer

Send it by email if the insurer gives an address for third-party claims, and keep a copy:

To: [insurer] claims department
Subject: Third-party claim against your policyholder [name], vehicle [registration]

On [date] at [time], at [place], your policyholder’s vehicle [registration], driven by [name], collided with my vehicle [registration]. [Two or three sentences on what happened and why your driver was at fault.] The accident was reported under case number [number].

I claim R[amount] for the repair of my vehicle, as set out in the attached quotes, and R[amount] for towing and storage. Attached: case number, photographs, quotes, my driving licence, my registration papers and witness statements. Please confirm receipt, give me a claim reference and tell me your decision in writing.

[Your name, phone number and email address]

Claiming when the other driver has no insurance

Then you claim from the driver personally: a letter of demand first, then the Small Claims Court, which takes claims of up to R30,000 since 1 August 2026, or the Magistrate’s Court above that.1 The steps, and what happens if you are the one without insurance, are in what happens if the other driver has no insurance.

If the other driver won’t give you their details

A driver who refuses breaks the law: the Road Traffic Act requires them to give their name and address and the owner’s details when asked, and to report the accident to the police themselves if it wasn’t reported at the scene; failing to give those details carries a fine or up to a year in prison.4,5 Take a photo of the number plate, note the car’s make and colour, and report it at the nearest police station; the case number lets your insurer, or you, trace the owner through the registration.

Claiming through your own insurer instead

If you have comprehensive cover, you can claim on your own policy: your insurer repairs your car and then recovers what it paid from the other driver or their insurer. That recovery is called subrogation. You usually pay your excess first, and the claim can affect your no-claim bonus until the recovery succeeds, so ask your insurer how it treats a not-at-fault claim.

It is often simpler when fault will be argued, because your insurer does the arguing. With third party insurance only, your own policy won’t repair your car, so you claim from the other side.

Time limits

A claim for damages against the other driver generally prescribes three years after it arises: the Prescription Act sets three years for “any other debt” unless another Act says otherwise.3 Your own insurer’s reporting deadline is much shorter and is in your policy, so report to it straight away even if you plan to claim from the other side.

If their insurer refuses or doesn’t answer

Ask for its reasons in writing and answer them with any evidence it didn’t have. If it still refuses, claim from the driver who caused the accident. The Department of Justice’s steps: ask them to settle; send a letter of demand by hand or registered post giving them 14 days to pay; then go to the clerk of the Small Claims Court at your nearest Magistrate’s Court, who prepares a summons; then the hearing.6 The limit is now R30,000; the Department’s 2025 poster still shows the old R20,000.1,6

Without comprehensive cover, you carry this yourself. Compare car insurance quotes.

Compare quotes

Questions people ask about claiming from someone else’s insurance

Yes. You can send a claim straight to the at-fault driver’s insurer with the case number, photos and repair quotes. It asks its own client first and then accepts, offers part payment or refuses.

Get their details and insurer at the scene, report the accident and keep the case number, then email their insurer’s claims department a claim with photos, repair quotes and your documents. Follow up in writing.

Yes, if their driver caused the damage. That is a third-party claim against their insurer. If you have comprehensive cover, you can also claim on your own policy and let your insurer recover from them.

Yes. You don’t need your own insurer to claim from the other driver’s insurer. If it refuses, your claim lies against the driver, through a letter of demand and the Small Claims Court for up to R30,000.

Yes. If you caused damage to someone else’s car, they can claim from your insurer under your policy’s third-party cover. Tell your insurer about the accident yourself as soon as you can.

It depends on the policy. Third-party cover follows the insured car and its approved drivers; some policies extend liability cover to you while you drive another car, so check the wording before you rely on it.

Generally three years from the accident, under the Prescription Act. Report to your own insurer much sooner, within the time your policy sets.

Sources

  1. SAnews (South African Government News Agency), “Small Claims Court limit raised to R30 000”, 23 July 2026, read 14 November 2026. sanews.gov.za
  2. Road Accident Fund Act 56 of 1996, “Section 17: Liability of Fund and agents (Acts Online copy)”, read 14 November 2026. acts.co.za
  3. Prescription Act 68 of 1969, “Section 11: Periods of prescription of debts (Acts Online copy)”, read 14 November 2026. acts.co.za
  4. National Road Traffic Act 93 of 1996, “Section 61: Duty of driver in event of accident (Acts Online copy)”, read 14 November 2026. acts.co.za
  5. National Road Traffic Act 93 of 1996, “Section 89: Offences and penalties (Acts Online copy)”, read 14 November 2026. acts.co.za
  6. Department of Justice and Constitutional Development, “Small Claims Court step-by-step guide (poster)”, 2025, read 14 November 2026. justice.gov.za

Insurers’ wordings, prices and rules are each insurer’s own published information unless a source says otherwise. They change, so confirm the details in your quote and on your policy schedule. Naming an insurer here does not mean it endorses OneCompare.