OneCompare

Claim scenario · Missed premium

Missed premium, then a claim

The debit order for your car insurance bounced, perhaps because the account changed or payday moved. You meant to sort it out, and before you did, there was an accident or the car was stolen. Whether the claim is paid now depends on dates: when the premium was due, when the loss happened, and whether the premium was ever paid. This page explains how those dates work and what to do the day a payment fails.

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 24 September 2026 · 6 min read

You pay for cover before you get it

A monthly car insurance premium pays for the month ahead. That is the point that decides most of these disputes: if the premium for a month was never paid, the insurer has not been paid for that month’s cover, and a loss during it can be refused.

Paying later does not always fix it. Settling the arrears after an accident may reinstate the policy going forward, but it is up to the insurer, and the policy wording, whether that reinstatement reaches back to cover a loss that already happened.

The grace period: at least 15 days, but not free cover

The Policyholder Protection Rules for short-term insurance, issued in 2017, require every policy to give a grace period of at least 15 days after the due date for paying a premium. On a monthly policy the rule applies from the second month, so the very first premium has no grace period. Your policy may allow longer; the schedule or the wording will say.

The grace period gives you time to pay before the policy can be cancelled for non-payment. It does not mean the month is covered whether or not you pay. If the premium is paid within the grace period, the policy carries on as normal. If it is never paid, a claim for a loss in that time can still be refused, and the policy can be cancelled once the grace period ends.

A case the Ombud decided

The National Financial Ombud Scheme has published a case that shows how this works. A motorist’s premium for March 2024 was not paid. The insurer tried to collect it twice, once during the grace period, and both attempts failed, so it cancelled the policy. On 13 April 2024 the car was damaged in an accident, and the insurer refused the claim.

The motorist said he had not known the payments failed, and offered to pay the arrears to have the policy reinstated. The Ombud agreed with the insurer: premiums are paid in advance, so to be covered in April the March premium had to be paid, and it was not.

How a debit order fails without you noticing

Most failed premiums are not a decision to stop paying. A new bank account is opened and the old debit order is never moved. A card is replaced and the insurer still has the old number. Payday moves, and the debit order now runs two days before the salary arrives. A debit order is disputed at the bank by mistake while clearing up other deductions.

In each case the insurer simply records an unpaid premium. Read every message from your bank about a returned debit order, and keep the insurer’s contact details where you can find them on the day.

If your claim was refused for non-payment

Ask for the reasons in writing, with the dates the insurer says the premium was due and the dates it tried to collect. Then check them against your bank statements. The case for you is strongest when the failure was not yours: the insurer debited the wrong account after you gave it new details, collected on a date you had not agreed, or recorded a payment you did make as unpaid.

Put your side to the insurer in writing with the statements attached. If it does not change its decision, you can take the complaint to the National Financial Ombud Scheme at no cost. Where the premium genuinely was unpaid when the loss happened, the case above shows how it is likely to end, which is why fixing a failed debit order the same day matters more than any argument afterwards.

For the time limits on reporting a claim, see how long a car insurance claim takes.

Step-by-step process

What to do the day a premium debit order fails

  1. 1

    Phone or message the insurer the same day

    Ask how to pay the missed premium now, by EFT or card, rather than waiting for the next debit order to run.

  2. 2

    Pay the missed month, not just the next one

    Next month’s debit pays for next month. The month that bounced stays unpaid until you pay it separately.

  3. 3

    Get confirmation in writing

    Ask for an email or a message confirming that the payment was received and that the policy is in force with no break in cover.

  4. 4

    Fix whatever made it fail

    Update the bank account or card details, or ask to move the debit date to just after your salary is paid.

  5. 5

    Check the next debit order goes through

    Look at the bank statement on the next collection date. One successful debit is the proof that the problem is solved.

The OneCompare view

A failed debit order costs nothing if it is fixed the same day, and can cost the whole claim if it is not. Treat the bank’s message as urgent, pay the missed month, and get the confirmation in writing.

Frequently asked questions

Missed premium, then a claim — common questions

The premium is unpaid and the grace period starts: at least 15 days after the due date, except on the first premium of a monthly policy. Pay within it and cover continues. Leave it unpaid and the insurer can refuse a claim for that time and cancel the policy.

Only if the premium is paid within it. The grace period gives you time to pay; it is not free cover. If the missed premium is never paid, a claim for a loss during the grace period can still be refused.

The insurer must tell you why in writing. You can then put your side to it with any evidence it did not have, such as bank statements showing the premium was paid, and if that fails, complain to the National Financial Ombud Scheme for free.

Have a claim question?

Get a free policy review

Upload your existing policy and we’ll review it free — confirming what’s actually covered and where the gaps are before you find out at claim time.