Why the use of the car decides the claim
When you take out car insurance you are asked how the car will be used, and the premium is worked out on that answer. A car that carries paying passengers or makes deliveries spends more hours on the road, often at night and in busy areas, so it is a different risk from a car used for family errands and the commute.
If a claim reveals that the car was being used in a way the policy does not cover, the insurer can reject it. Two separate things can sink the claim: an exclusion (many private policies simply do not cover carrying passengers or goods for reward), or non-disclosure (you did not tell the insurer something it needed to know to price the risk).
For non-disclosure, South African law sets a test. Under section 53 of the Short-term Insurance Act, an insurer cannot reject a claim or cancel a policy because of an incorrect or missing answer unless that answer was likely to have materially affected its assessment of the risk, judged by what a reasonable, prudent person would consider should have been disclosed. The Supreme Court of Appeal added in Regent Insurance v King’s Property Development (2014) that the insurer must also show the non-disclosure induced it to take on the risk. Regular paid trips in a car declared for private use usually pass that test, which is why these claims are so often lost.
What counts as business use, and what counts as "for reward"
Proposal forms usually ask you to choose between private use, private and business use, and business use, with business use meaning travel for your work beyond the commute: visiting clients, sites or customers. That is about where you drive.
Carrying passengers or goods for reward is different. It means someone pays for the trip or the delivery, which is what e-hailing and delivery apps are. Many standard car policies exclude it even when business use is declared, so ticking "business" is not the same as being covered for app work. Ask about it by name.
How it comes to light
Usually through the ordinary claim questions: where you were going, why, and who was in the car. A passenger in the back seat, a delivery bag on the seat or an app open on a phone holder answers those questions for you.
If the insurer has doubts, it can investigate further: the accident report, statements from the other driver or witnesses, tracker trip history, and, in a formal dispute, records from the app. Mileage far above what was declared can also prompt questions. None of this needs to be dramatic; one honest answer at the claim stage is often enough to show the car was working at the time.
If your claim has already been rejected
Ask for the reasons in writing. Under the Policyholder Protection Rules an insurer must give you the reasons for rejecting a claim, and you have at least 90 days to make representations, that is, to put your side and any new facts to the insurer. Those 90 days cannot be counted in any time limit your policy sets for taking legal action, and the policy must allow at least six months after they end.
Look closely at what the decision relies on. Was it an exclusion in the policy, or non-disclosure? If it is non-disclosure, was the trip in question really paid work, how often did you do it, and was the use you declared genuinely wrong? A one-off favour for a friend is not the same as running an app every weekend.
If the insurer’s internal complaints process does not resolve it, you can take the complaint to the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO), which since 1 March 2024 handles the short-term insurance complaints that the Ombudsman for Short-term Insurance used to deal with. The service is free to consumers.
Getting the cover right for app or delivery work
There is no single answer, because insurers treat this work differently: some will add it to a policy, some offer cover designed for e-hailing or delivery drivers, and some will not cover it at all. What matters is that the use you declare matches what you actually do, and that the answer you rely on is in writing.
If you drive for an e-hailing app, our guide to insurance for Uber and Bolt drivers sets out what to ask. If you deliver food or groceries in your own car or on a scooter, see the delivery driver guide. Either way, comparing quotes with the use declared correctly is the only comparison that means anything, because a cheaper quote on the wrong use is not cover.
Step-by-step process
How to put your policy right before the next trip
- 1
Write down how the car is really used
Private driving, commuting, visiting clients, carrying paying passengers, delivering goods for a fee. Note roughly how often each happens. This is what your insurer needs to hear, in your own words.
- 2
Read the "use" line on your schedule
Your policy schedule shows the use the premium was worked out on. Read the exclusions too: many private car policies exclude carrying passengers or goods for reward altogether, whatever the use line says.
- 3
Tell your insurer before you start
Ask directly: "I drive for an e-hailing app" or "I do deliveries on weekends" — "am I covered while I do this, and what changes?" Ask for the answer in writing.
- 4
Check what the app itself covers
Some platforms arrange protection for drivers during trips, aimed at injury rather than damage to the car. Find out exactly what it pays for and when; it does not replace your own motor policy.
- 5
Keep the paper trail
Keep the email or the endorsement that records your declared use, and update it when the work starts, grows or stops.
The OneCompare view
Declaring app or delivery work costs a higher premium; not declaring it can cost the whole car. The fix is a short conversation before the first paid trip, and an answer you can show in writing.