How each is fitted
A hardwired unit is connected to the car's electrical system and runs on its power. A fitter has to remove trim, run the wiring to a hidden spot and connect it properly, so it is a booked job at a fitment centre, and you usually leave the car for it.
A wireless unit has its own battery and no connection to the car's wiring. It can go almost anywhere a small sealed box will fit, so fitting it is quicker, and some products are sold for owners to fit themselves. The battery has to be charged or replaced from time to time, which a hardwired unit never needs; our page on battery and always-on trackers covers that side.
Which is harder for a thief to find
A hardwired unit has to sit within reach of the wiring that feeds it, and a thief who knows what to look for can follow that wiring to it. A wireless unit has no wiring to follow, so it can be put where a quick search will miss it.
Neither is invisible to a determined search, and a well-hidden hardwired unit is harder to find than a wireless one left in an obvious place. Whichever you choose, ask the fitter where the unit will go and how it is protected against tampering.
What your insurer accepts
If your policy makes a tracker a condition of cover, the insurer decides which devices count, and often how they must be fitted. A product on the insurer's list can still fall short if you fitted it yourself where the insurer asks for a professional fitment and a certificate; our page on insurer-approved trackers explains what approval means.
So before you buy a self-fit wireless unit to save the fitting cost, check two things with your insurer, in writing: that the product is accepted, and that fitting it yourself is. Then keep the fitment certificate or the insurer's confirmation with your policy documents.
On a financed car
A bank that finances a car expects it to be comprehensively insured, and if that policy has a tracking condition, the condition applies in full. A theft claim that fails on it still leaves you owing the bank, so make sure the device and the way it was fitted meet the policy before you rely on them.
When no insurer condition applies
If your insurer does not require a tracker and you want one for your own peace of mind, a wireless unit is often the simpler choice: quick to fit and easy to hide.
What decides whether it helps on the day is the same for any tracker: that it is still charged and reporting, that it is hidden well, how it copes with a signal jammer, and how quickly the provider responds when the car is taken. Our page on anti-jamming covers the jammer question.
The OneCompare view
Wireless or hardwired is the smaller question. The bigger ones are whether your insurer accepts the device and the way it was fitted, and how well it is hidden. Settle those first, in writing, and the choice between the two follows.