Insurance glossary
Indemnity
Also known as: principle of indemnity
Quick definition
The principle that insurance puts you back in the financial position you were in just before a loss, no better and no worse. It is why a write-off pays the car’s value at the time, not what you paid for it.
Indemnity on a car claim
Insurance is compensation for a loss, not a way to come out ahead. So a repair claim pays to restore the car to the condition it was in, and a theft or write-off pays its value at the time of the loss, on the basis your schedule shows, rather than its purchase price.
Two everyday rules follow from it. If a repair leaves the car better than it was, for example a new part replacing a worn one, the insurer may ask you to pay for the improvement, which is called betterment. And because a car’s value falls with time, the settlement on an older car is lower than the price you once paid.
The same principle explains two other rules. Once an insurer has paid the full value of a written-off or stolen car, the car becomes the insurer’s property, because you have been compensated for it. And if two policies cover the same loss, you cannot collect twice: the insurers share the claim between them, which is known as contribution.
Agreed value is the main exception: for some cars, such as classics, the insurer and the owner agree a value at the start, and that figure is paid on a total loss.
Related terms
Definitions reviewed by the OneCompare editorial team. OneCompare (Pty) Ltd is an Authorised Financial Services Provider (FSP 55551).
← Back to the full glossary