OneCompare
Updated 3 September 2026 · 4 min read

Dashcams · Comparison

Dashcam or Vehicle Tracker: Which Do You Need?

A tracker and a dashcam protect you against different losses: one helps get a stolen car back, the other shows what happened in a collision. Your insurer may settle part of the question for you. Here is how to work out the rest.

Two devices, two different jobs

A tracker is a hidden unit that reports the car’s position, usually backed by a recovery service that works to find the car if it is stolen or hijacked. Its job starts when the car has gone. For how a dash cam works on its own, start with what a dashcam is.

A dashcam is a camera that records the road, and sometimes the view behind or inside the car. Its job is to show what happened in a collision or another incident. It does not help find a stolen car, and because it is visible, a thief can remove it or take it with the car.

Start with what your insurer requires

For some vehicles, insurers make an approved tracker a condition of theft and hijacking cover. If your insurer requires one for your car, that settles the order: the tracker comes first, because a theft claim can depend on it. Our page on when insurers require a tracker explains the usual triggers.

A dashcam is rarely a condition of cover for a private car, and several insurers have said publicly that they do not discount for one. Our page on dashcam insurance discounts covers what a camera can still do for what you pay.

If you can only have one

Where your insurer leaves the choice to you, ask which loss worries you more: losing the whole car to theft or hijacking, or an argument about who caused a collision. The value of the car, where it is parked, how much you drive and in what traffic all shift the answer.

The costs work differently too. A tracker usually comes with a monthly subscription for as long as you keep it, while a dashcam is usually a once-off purchase and fitting, with a memory card to replace from time to time. Compare the total over the time you expect to keep the car. Our page on tracker monthly costs explains what the subscription covers.

When both make sense

Both are worth considering when both risks are real: a car that is often targeted by thieves and also spends long hours in heavy traffic, or a vehicle used for work, such as deliveries or e-hailing, that is on the road for much of the day. The two devices do not overlap, so one does not reduce the need for the other.

Devices that do some of both

Some connected dashcams can show the car’s location in an app, and some tracking companies offer cameras alongside their trackers. A camera that shows a location is not necessarily a tracker your insurer approves, so if your policy has a tracking condition, ask the insurer in writing whether the product you are considering meets it.

Fitting them

A tracker is usually fitted by the tracking company’s installer, who issues a fitment certificate your insurer may ask for. A dashcam can be plugged into the power socket or hardwired by a fitter. The two are independent, so you can fit one now and the other later. Our page on fitment certificates explains what the certificate shows.

Frequently asked questions

Dashcam vs tracker — common questions

No. A dashcam records what happens around the car, but it does not help find the car once it is stolen. If your insurer requires a tracker, a dashcam does not meet that condition.

If your insurer requires a tracker for your car, fit the tracker first. Otherwise, start with the device that covers the loss you are more worried about: theft of the whole car, or a dispute about a collision.

Only a little. A camera set up for parking mode may record the theft, but it cannot show where the car went, and thieves can remove it. Finding the car is a tracker’s job.

Only if your insurer says so. A camera that shows a location in an app is not necessarily an approved tracker, so ask in writing before you rely on one.

Compare insurance + tracker quotes

Pair your dashcam with the right car insurance and tracker setup. Get tailored quotes from South African insurers — obligation-free.