OneCompare
Updated 8 June 2026 · 6 min read

Dashcams & insurance · Disputes

When the Other Driver Disputes the Accident: How Dashcam Footage Helps

After a collision, each driver tells a version in which the other one caused it, and the two insurers have to agree who pays. Without independent evidence that can take months and end in a compromise. This page explains how a disputed claim is settled between insurers, where dashcam footage changes the outcome, and what to do if your claim stalls.

What a disputed claim looks like

A claim is disputed when the drivers, and then their insurers, disagree about who caused the accident. The collisions that produce the most arguments are the ones where both versions are plausible: a lane change on a highway, two cars arriving at a four-way stop, a robot that one driver says was green and the other says was orange, a rear-end collision after sudden braking, two cars reversing out of parking bays at the same time. For the basics of how a dash cam records, start with our hub.

What makes them hard is that the usual evidence is the drivers’ own statements, and each statement is honest about what that driver saw. A witness with nothing to gain helps. A recording made at the time, which nobody can retell, helps more.

How the insurers settle it

If you have comprehensive cover, you can claim from your own insurer for your car whoever caused the accident. You pay your excess, your insurer repairs the car, and it then tries to recover what it paid from the other driver or the other driver’s insurer. That recovery is where the dispute is fought, usually between the two insurers rather than by you.

When the evidence does not point clearly one way, insurers may agree to share the cost, or the recovery may stall altogether. You feel the result in two places: whether you get your excess back, and how the claim is treated at renewal. Both depend on how much your insurer recovered and on what your policy says.

Where footage changes the outcome

Footage helps most on the questions statements cannot settle: which lane each car was in a second before contact, whether an indicator was on, what colour the robot showed, how far ahead a car braked and how hard. A rear camera matters as much as the front one, because many disputed collisions happen beside or behind you.

It does not have to show everything to be useful. A clip that proves one fact, such as the other car crossing a solid line, can be enough to move the decision. Send what you have to your insurer early, and say plainly what it shows and what it does not.

Give your insurer something it can use

The footage is evidence only if it is intact: the original file, with the date and time the camera saved, not a trimmed or re-recorded copy. Our page on dashcam evidence explains how to secure a clip before it is recorded over and what to send with it.

Make your written statement match the footage. Describe what happened as you remember it, then let the clip confirm it. An account that the clip contradicts, even on a detail, gives the other side a reason to doubt the rest.

When the other side has no insurance, or will not engage

If the other driver has no insurance, your insurer recovers from that driver personally, which is slower and less certain. Footage still matters, because it is what a demand letter or a court relies on. If you have no comprehensive cover of your own, you must claim from the other driver yourself, and the footage may be the strongest evidence you have.

A driver who claims against you for an accident you did not cause is in the same position in reverse: tell your insurer straight away, send the footage, and let it respond.

If your claim stalls

Ask your insurer in writing where the recovery stands, what the other side has said, and whether your footage has been considered. If the insurer has decided the matter in a way you think ignores clear evidence, use its complaints process and ask for the final answer in writing.

After that, the National Financial Ombud Scheme can review the insurer’s handling of your claim at no cost to you. A complaint with the original footage and a clear timeline attached is easy to follow.

Frequently asked questions

Dashcams in disputed claims — common questions

Each driver claims from their own insurer if they have comprehensive cover, and the insurers then argue over who pays. Without clear evidence they may agree to share the cost, or the recovery may stall. Independent evidence, such as footage or a witness, is what moves it.

Only if your insurer recovers what it paid from the other side and your policy provides for refunding the excess. Ask your insurer how it treats the excess on a claim it recovers in full, and in part.

Having one rarely changes the premium on its own, but footage can change the outcome of a claim, especially a disputed one. Tell your insurer you have it, and ask whether the camera must be listed on your schedule to be covered if it is stolen.

Compare insurance + tracker quotes

Pair your dashcam with the right car insurance and tracker setup. Get tailored quotes from South African insurers — obligation-free.