OneCompare

Claim scenario · Not at fault

Not at fault accident

When another driver causes the accident, their side should carry the cost of your damage. There are two ways to get there: through your own insurer, which is usually quicker, or by claiming from the other driver's insurer yourself. Which is better depends on how clear the fault is and how soon you need the car.

By OneCompare Editorial · Updated 12 October 2026 · 6 min read

Two ways to get your car repaired

You can claim on your own comprehensive policy. Your insurer assesses and repairs the car under your cover, you pay your excess, and your insurer then recovers what it paid from the driver who caused the accident or from that driver's insurer. This is called subrogation.

Or you can claim directly from the other driver's insurer as a third party. Their policy's liability cover pays for damage they cause to other people's property, so you pay no excess and nothing is claimed on your own policy. You do more of the work yourself, and the other insurer must first accept that its client was at fault.

Claiming through your own insurer

This is usually the quicker route to a repaired car, because your insurer deals with you under the terms you already have. You pay the excess shown on your schedule when the claim is settled.

If your insurer recovers the money from the at-fault side, you should get your excess back; ask your insurer to confirm this and to tell you when recovery succeeds. How a not-at-fault claim affects your no-claim bonus varies between insurers, so ask before you claim rather than after.

Claiming from the other driver's insurer

Write to the other driver's insurer with the accident details, the police accident report number, your photos and at least one repair quote. They will usually want to hear their own client's account and may send their assessor to look at your car.

This route suits clear-cut cases where you can manage without the car for a while and want to keep your own policy out of it. If the other insurer disputes fault, delays, or its client turns out not to have cover, you can still claim on your own policy, as long as you report within the time your policy allows. That is another reason to tell your insurer about the accident straight away.

Proving it was not your fault

Fault is decided on the evidence: the accident report, photographs, independent witnesses, and dashcam or CCTV footage. A statement at the scene from the other driver admitting fault helps, but insurers rely on the physical evidence too.

Some situations are usually clear, such as being hit from behind while stationary, because the following driver must keep a safe distance. Collisions at intersections and during lane changes are often disputed, and in those cases independent witnesses and footage carry the most weight.

If the other driver has no insurance

If the other driver turns out to be uninsured, there is no insurer to claim from, and your options change: your own comprehensive cover, or a claim against the driver personally. Our guide for when an uninsured driver hits you explains both, including the Small Claims Court.

Without comprehensive cover of your own, see how to claim from someone else’s insurance.

Footage from a dash cam is the strongest evidence that you weren’t at fault.

Step-by-step process

What to do when the other driver was at fault

  1. 1

    Record the scene

    Photograph both cars, their positions, the road, traffic lights and signs, skid marks and the other car's number plate. Note the time and exact place.

  2. 2

    Get the other driver's details

    Full name, ID number, phone number, address, licence and vehicle registration, and the name of their insurer if they have one. Write down the details of any witnesses.

  3. 3

    Report the accident to the police

    If no officer came to the scene, report it at a police station without delay and keep the accident report number.

  4. 4

    Tell your own insurer

    Tell your insurer even if you plan to claim from the other driver's insurer; policies generally require you to report any accident, and your insurer can tell you which route suits the facts.

  5. 5

    Choose your route and keep copies

    Claim on your own policy, or lodge a third-party claim with the other driver's insurer. Either way, keep every quote, letter and reference number.

The OneCompare view

Report the accident to your own insurer straight away, even if you hope to claim from the other side. It keeps both routes open, and the evidence you collect at the scene is what decides who pays.

Frequently asked questions

Not at fault accident — common questions

It depends on your insurer. Some treat a claim they recover in full differently from an at-fault claim; others record any claim. Ask your insurer how a not-at-fault claim affects your no-claim bonus and renewal before you decide which route to use.

With evidence collected at the time: photos of both cars and the road, the police accident report number, independent witness details, and dashcam or CCTV footage. Give it to whichever insurer is handling the claim as early as you can.

On your own policy, usually yes, at first; you should get it back if your insurer recovers its costs from the at-fault side. If you claim directly from the other driver's insurer, you pay no excess.

Yes. You lodge a third-party claim with their insurer, which pays for the damage its client caused if it accepts that its client was at fault. Keep your own insurer informed in case you need to claim on your policy instead.

Ask for its reasons in writing and send any evidence it has not seen. If the dispute continues, claim on your own policy and let your insurer pursue the recovery; that is part of what your cover is for.

Have a claim question?

Get a free policy review

Upload your existing policy and we’ll review it free — confirming what’s actually covered and where the gaps are before you find out at claim time.