The usual reasons hail claims are rejected
The cover type. Hail damage to your own car is paid only on comprehensive cover. Third-party, fire and theft and third-party only policies do not cover it, so a rejection on that ground is simply the policy working as written.
Older damage presented as hail. Dents from earlier knocks, parking bumps or a previous storm are not covered by the new claim. Where old and new damage sit on the same panels, the insurer pays the hail damage it can identify and excludes the rest.
Details that do not match the storm. If the claim says the car was parked at home, but the storm did not hit that area or the car was elsewhere at the time, the insurer will question the claim, even if the damage is genuine. The circumstances you report must be the true ones.
Late reporting. Policies require claims to be reported within a set time. A claim lodged long after the storm, for example only when the car is being sold, makes it hard to show that the damage came from that storm.
Repairs before the assessment. If the car was repaired before the insurer saw it, the insurer cannot verify what was damaged or what it cost, and may refuse or reduce the claim.
How an assessor tells hail from older damage
Hail falls from above, so fresh hail damage is spread across the roof, bonnet, boot lid and the tops of the doors and pillars, with round dents of similar size and unbroken paint. Damage that sits low on the car, under the bumpers or in the wheel arches, or dents with cracked paint, rust at the edges or scrape marks, points to a different cause.
Assessors also check the circumstances: whether a storm hit that area at that time, what other claims came in from nearby, and, if the car has a tracker, where it was parked. When those line up with your account, the claim is straightforward.
Carports, trees and partial payments
A carport or tree can protect the roof and bonnet while wind-driven hail marks the sides of the car. Because that pattern is less typical, the assessor may accept part of the damage and reject part of it. Photographs of the parking spot, of nearby cars and of debris after the storm help to show the hail came in sideways.
If you are offered a partial payment or a cash settlement instead of a repair, get your own repair quote before you accept, and ask the insurer to explain any item it has left out. Accepting a settlement usually closes the claim.
Making your case
Answer the reason you were given, not the whole claim again. If the insurer says the damage is old, show when the panels were last seen undamaged. If it says the car was elsewhere, show where it was. If it says the claim was late, explain why and when you first noticed the damage.
Keep it in writing and keep copies. If the insurer’s final answer is still no, the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO) took over the work of the Ombudsman for Short-term Insurance on 1 March 2024 and handles these complaints at no cost to you.
Step-by-step process
What to do when a hail claim is rejected
- 1
Get the reasons in writing
Under the Policyholder Protection Rules the insurer must tell you why it rejected the claim. If you only had a phone call, ask for the decision and the reasons in writing.
- 2
Match each reason to your evidence
Date-stamped photos, where the car was during the storm (tracker history if you have it), weather warnings and news reports for that afternoon, and a recent service or inspection report that shows the panels before the storm.
- 3
Make representations in time
The Policyholder Protection Rules give you at least 90 days from the rejection to put your side and any new evidence to the insurer. Those days cannot be counted in any time limit your policy sets for legal action, and the policy must allow at least six months after they end.
- 4
Use the insurer’s complaints process
Ask for the complaint to be escalated beyond the claims department, and keep a record of every reference number and date.
- 5
Take it to the National Financial Ombud
If the insurer does not change its decision, the National Financial Ombud Scheme considers short-term insurance complaints free of charge.
The OneCompare view
A rejected hail claim is worth challenging when the reason given does not fit the facts. Answer that reason with evidence, in writing and within the time allowed, and use the National Financial Ombud Scheme if the insurer will not move.